I must admit our clan has been getting fair matches now o.o
Last war it was a .22% difference that decided the winning team
I must admit our clan has been getting fair matches now o.o
Last war it was a .22% difference that decided the winning team
I can't agree with you here. They had 20 (!!!) th11 attacks, we had 8. It's hard to loose with so many chances to hit those top bases.Originally Posted by TheWarDictator
Start Date: 15 Oct 2014
|| TH10 28 Sept 2015 || 275 magma || BK40 AQ40 [finally @ 29 Feb 2016] || GW20 @ 2 July 2016 ||
it makes me sigh to see this simplistic logic constantly repeated, you should think through how when you upgrade to the next townhall you will match to a maxed townhall of that level. "ohhh how is it fair his queen is level 30 and mine is level 1"
see your fix?
It's so simple, even a caveman can figure it out... I'm not saying that TH should be matched, but I do think that TH level should have the heaviest weight.
Engineered bases only exist to manipulate the mm algorithm and create an unfair advantage.
Why are there always a few people trying to justify these terrible matchups? Or trying to blame the disadvantaged clan? It should not be possible for a th11 sitting down in tenth amongst th8's to come up and three star a number one max th10 in no fantasy land is that fair or logical it just should not be possible...... Hopefully it gets fixed cause it ain't fun to be on the receiving end of a really unfair fight.
Short of reading through 1.7k replies, can I have a quick consensus on how is war matching now (before coming update)?
Am I right to say:
1. For engineering clans, you'll get matched to other engineering clans. There might be severe mismatches but it's fair game since you chose this route.
2. For non engineering clans, matching has improved substantially and you won't get matched against engineering clans too often.
That is the sense I'm getting.
Please use general trends (say, more than half the time) over sufficient number of wars to comment and not base on occasional mismatches.
My leader has insisted that everyone engineers but I'm trying to convince him that it's not advantageous to do so anymore.
Thank you!
Too many people over here don't understand business. Weighting the TH = penalizing rushers = penalizing a HUGE part of their player base. The forums are just a tiny % of their base.
On topic, dropping a max TH11 and a super TH9 -our others are super 8 (except top 2)- improved our match, how's that? We lost our WS because of a horrible mismatch (against 2 fully maxed TH11s we lost by 1%), so we tried to do something new. Usually it's 0 vs 2 eagles and 0 vs 5 IT. Now it was 1 vs 0 eagles a 1 vs 4 IT. Matchmaking used to take 5 minutes and since last update it's taking 50 minutes.
I think you are the one who does not understand. Rushers are all have been punished by weight. And it still does up to this point. When rushers upgrade his/her th to th 9, they immediately will build x bows, regardless their canon or tesla still level 1 or 2. As soon as they reach th 10, they will immediately build infernos and th11 with eagle.
This way, they already immediately matched with their respectively th in war.
If they do not build the new defense item right away (wait for couple months), they already fall to the category of eng bases, not rushers anymore. That is how you differentiate regular rushers vs eng bases. Regular rushers does not even care nor (maybe) understand about the weighting system in clan wars.
Current matchmaking is complete rubbish.
Our current match (25 man war) is
2 TH 11 v 3 TH 11 (one engineered)
2 x TH 10 x 9 TH 10 (one rushed four engineered)
11 TH 9 v 4 TH 9
Looking at this war lineup I think there can only be one result.
We've had worse and won. We don't even have the 3 max 11s up top. Like i said, it's not the worse when it comes to mismatches.
