Uneven match!!...ENGINEERED BASES

[Ripple1972]

In my opinion it is a simple fix here, have 2 types of wars, one for non engineered clans and one for engineered. A simple calculated value will determine defence versus offence and produce a threshold for engineered. Once the EClans are forced to face other EClans then the advantage will evaporate.

Awesome. Please define exactly the difference between an engineered and non engineered clan.

[BlackDragonD]

Awesome. Please define exactly the difference between an engineered and non engineered clan.

not that its gonna make any difference since a new MM will be released soon, but i'd say the minimum should be >10% of war size.
meaning more than 1 engineered base for the smallest of wars (10x10), more than 2 for 20x20 and so on.

So if a clan has 2 engineered bases in 10x10 war it will be called engineered for this matter.

[Ripple1972]

not that its gonna make any difference since a new MM will be released soon, but i'd say the minimum should be >10% of war size.
meaning more than 1 engineered base for the smallest of wars (10x10), more than 2 for 20x20 and so on.

So if a clan has 2 engineered bases in 10x10 war it will be called engineered for this matter.

Awesome, please define an engineered base.

[Captainpauld]

Awesome, please define an engineered base.

An engineered base is any TH with firing defences that are 2 or more levels below the TH level. So for example a TH 9 with level 2 cannons and archer towers would be considered engineered for the purposes of this exercise. Pretty simple to calculate

[2222]

An engineered base is any TH with firing defences that are 2 or more levels below the TH level. So for example a TH 9 with level 2 cannons and archer towers would be considered engineered for the purposes of this exercise. Pretty simple to calculate

So as long as I only have my defenses one full hall level below my actual hall (thus, my offense), I get to war in the "not engineered" matches?

[Warios]

not that its gonna make any difference since a new MM will be released soon, but i'd say the minimum should be >10% of war size.
meaning more than 1 engineered base for the smallest of wars (10x10), more than 2 for 20x20 and so on.

So if a clan has 2 engineered bases in 10x10 war it will be called engineered for this matter.

So if a clan wars with th10's at the top, this will limit them facing only 2 th11's at the bottom of the map with 45/45/20, instead of the 5 or 6 that can happen?

[posthoc]

So as long as I only have my defenses one full hall level below my actual hall (thus, my offense), I get to war in the "not engineered" matches?

Gosh, it almost seems as if this would engender even more precise engineering than the current state of affairs!

[Ripple1972]

An engineered base is any TH with firing defences that are 2 or more levels below the TH level. So for example a TH 9 with level 2 cannons and archer towers would be considered engineered for the purposes of this exercise. Pretty simple to calculate

So for a 10 v 10 war.
I can put in a dless th11 45-45-20, as my engineered base. My 10%.
And the rest can be any maxed offense th, with defenses 1 th lower.

and I would be in the non engineered spin.

sign me up.

[TankSinatra]

An engineered base is any TH with firing defences that are 2 or more levels below the TH level. So for example a TH 9 with level 2 cannons and archer towers would be considered engineered for the purposes of this exercise. Pretty simple to calculate

So you're saying you run .5s?

[Vikingchief]

Awesome, please define an engineered base.

An engineered base is any TH with firing defences that are 2 or more levels below the TH level. So for example a TH 9 with level 2 cannons and archer towers would be considered engineered for the purposes of this exercise. Pretty simple to calculate

So as long as I only have my defenses one full hall level below my actual hall (thus, my offense), I get to war in the "not engineered" matches?

hmm, Im feel like Ive seen this discussion before somewhere.

Im so tempted to chime in but it wasnt funny the first time.