Like many others, I am getting tired of engineered bases. I still dont see why matchmaking needs to be complicated. Just use TH level and thats it. If I have 10xTH9 and 5xTH8 in my team, match me against the same. I would rather a longer wait for a match up and have a sensible war than a quick matchup against a one sided battle.
Started June 2014. TH 12. Lvl 216. Trophy record 5265. Last updated June 2019.
Perpetual ignorance - being satisfied with your opinions and content with your knowledge
Any change, even a change for the better, is always accompanied by drawbacks and discomforts.
yep. just like how they broke 16:10 android tablets last update, and no staff has said a word about it.Originally Posted by Skrags
Do you mean like the TH11 update just before the Xmas holidays?
Are you suggesting an announcement and then :-
only a helpful mod.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...-so-big/page50
break the game and run!
So then you wouldn't mind your new TH9 with level 1 X-Bows, level 10 King, Level 1 Queen and TH8 troops, matching against a maxed TH9 with level 3 X-Bows, level 30 heroes and max Th9 troops? Since you're asking for straight TH matching without thought to the actual development levels of the respective bases..............
Why couldn't they match another new th9 with level 1 bows, level 1 queen, th8 troops? Why does it mean they have to match a maxed th9? You're making this out like maxed 9s would love to prey on new 9s. That's not necessary true. Some would love to face them, some like me wouldn't. I didn't spend years of my life perfecting my craft to use against inferior competition. I'll take a maxed 9 on go one...
Wait, who is complaining about losing to a townhall their own level? No one...
Read what he wrote. Simple TH to TH matching. Period. Which would not make the situation any better than it currently is.
I'm not saying it couldn't match new TH9 to new TH9, but if it's strictly based on TH VS TH matching, what are the chances of that? If it's set up as TH VS TH, then in the eyes of the MM a new TH9 is no different than a max TH9.
Because there wasnt one searching. The existing MM would have found the match if it was that exact. The question is what happens when there isn't a perfect match (ie always)
Various data posts: Who plays what? CWL data 1 (stars), 2 (3* rates), 3 (rosters), 4 (start times and other) Data at end of old Legends And (non-data) how max bases are ordered in war
The chances would be zero for those who match my clan because we wouldn't let a brand new th9 be in our wars if it was straight hall matching.
Informal poll: in your matchups, how many non-max bases do you see for every max or near-max at th9 and th10?
I'm hesitant even to hazard a guess because human brains are notoriously bad at estimating frequencies of rare events; but for us at least, encountering a max base is rare enough to be noteworthy. It has to be at least a 10:1 ratio.
Last edited by posthoc; July 27th, 2017 at 04:34 PM.
Well said! Yea the most unforgettable wars are those that are the most evenly matched across the board offensively, defensively and equally skilled.
That would change if the game moved to TH level matching. Engineers would permabase and crush their opponents. High end competitive clans would have massive advantages in random spins, especially random spins that do not occur at potluck times.
Posting Permissions
