Proposed New Builder Base Loot System [With Pictures... YAY!]

[VeeBirds]

Still, 10 is a REALLY HIGH number of wins to get per day, except for the maxed peeps that have almost nothing to work on on their main village.

If I could suggest, I'd say something like this would be great IMO:
Win #1 - normal bonus
Win #2 - special bonus slightly higher
Win #3 - normal bonus
Win #4 - special bonus slightly higher than #2
Win #5 - normal bonus
Win #6 - ultimate bonus
Win #7 to infinite - minimal bonus

(It's a bit like the progressive bonus you get in some Royale's special challenges)

[Pimmiepim]

Continuing to provide bonuses (no matter how small) after a number of wins encourages botting. Probably a reason not to do it for SC.

[Bangre]

I agree, increase loot at 10th win or give bonus at 3, 5 & 10 wins. Continuous loot will encourage botting.

[Saleh47]

Continuing to provide bonuses (no matter how small) after a number of wins encourages botting. Probably a reason not to do it for SC.

The thing that won't work much with bots is the need to win & not tie, wait for opponent to finish & wait for army to finish. So they can't do the fast farming thing with this as easy it would look. Over the time it might get them somewhere but probably not further than the normal player thus their advantage is minimal imo

[bigwinw]

I have no faith that SC will make any changes to loot in this mode.

[Redcard1]

At first I would have been all for this however now that I have maxed some troops and have all defense up to max BH level 4 I'm not so sure my last 10 marchers are ties...100% destructions and I have brought down a few maxed BH5s in this it seems offense is stronger then defense right now and that's not good when a tie does nothing but make you wait for your troops to raid again...

[Redcard1]

I guess I forgot to explain why this would be bad my last loss was 14 raids ago my last win was 12 so if I win 1 out of 12 it would take me 120+ raids a day to get my loot...

[Superfinch30]

The thing that won't work much with bots is the need to win & not tie, wait for opponent to finish & wait for army to finish. So they can't do the fast farming thing with this as easy it would look. Over the time it might get them somewhere but probably not further than the normal player thus their advantage is minimal imo

This. The bot has to be able to outperform a real person.

Liking v5. I must say, the loot cap and builder time DO seem to be reasonably well balanced.....but it doesn't account for walls.
BH3 has lv3s available at 100k per section.
Throw those in the mix, then the current system is a nonsense.

Walls would seriously benefit from some of these revisions. It gives plenty of progress for casual/minimal play, but the hardcores can get their walls done.
That's appealing to the normal village mindset.

[JJaaoo]

I like the #V5 version Lach provided.

Sounds good to me, great job on creating that man

[Zelonius]

So here is V5 (ignore the text at the bottom, will change if you guys like this idea).
Win #3 is a huge bonus so that resources are somewhat the same as now for the first 3 wins. After 3 wins, you earn a small amount up until 10 wins. After 10 wins, you continue to earn a super small resource bonus per win.

This allows the casual player who likes the current 3 win system to still earn the same loot at 3 wins.
It allows the competitive player to continue playing for a further 7 wins earning some nice loot.
And then for the hardcore players - they can continue on even after 10 wins for a small trickle.

Something is better than nothing