Build.a.Clan.💥New.Feature.Request ! Best.Idea.is.Here👍

[842]

I've seen this idea pop up a number of times, and it's really confusing to me, because it is such a bad idea. This definitely falls into the "absolutely never" category.

[Cilakila]

To Make this Idea Hopper Proof.
The Joining Members Cannot Leave For 30Days You can Decide who shall Join Your Clan permission is needed
and if you disagree then simple you
"don't have to" Join that clan and get stuck for 30 days Simple

When I Tried To Build a Clan.
All I Could find was 2 or 3 good Clashers After lvl 2 Clan Perk I quit.

Several things.

What if someone joins this clan. Now, I do not know how much you know about most clans, but the recruiter goes crazy for two hours recruiting to his clan - gets five clashers to join - then goes offline and is never back on again. If I joined xxbeastbodexx in his "Best Clan" I am required to stay for 30 days even if he and the other clashers go inactive? That won't be much fun. I think I will quit too.

Next. You realize how many clans I once joined and immediately got "So are you hot?" Why would I want to stay?

Next - it is hard to build a clan. I will not recommend doing it unless you have hours each day to be in global or you have connections.

[rwelshjr]

If You like the idea Then reply it Gets More Views.

This idea Will Help Clashers to find
Clanmates and Make sure they Stay.

There Would Be a Start a Clan option in Global Chat. When You Press it
There Would appear a tab Where Clashers Can Join you.
At least 10 Members needed to start a Clan.

So The Tab Remains in Global Chat till u find 9 players in Your Global. How Many will Join Can Be Set 50 will Be Maximum.

If You have played Clash royale It will be the same tab when you look for a freindly battle in Clash Royale
and
To Make this Idea Hopper Proof.
The Joining Members Cannot Leave For 30Days You can Decide who shall Join Your Clan permission is needed
and
if you disagree then simple you
"don't have to" Join that clan and get stuck for 30 days Simple

When I Tried To Build a Clan.
All I Could find was 2 or 3 good Clashers After lvl 2 Clan Perk I quit.

Although I dont think the idea adds value to the recruiting process, one aspect that did appeal to me was how it would form a bunch of Roach Motels for hoppers. Hoppers go in but they dont come out! Sweet!

[George1971]

If You like the idea Then reply it Gets More Views.

This idea Will Help Clashers to find
Clanmates and Make sure they Stay.

There Would Be a Start a Clan option in Global Chat. When You Press it
There Would appear a tab Where Clashers Can Join you.
At least 10 Members needed to start a Clan.

So The Tab Remains in Global Chat till u find 9 players in Your Global. How Many will Join Can Be Set 50 will Be Maximum.

If You have played Clash royale It will be the same tab when you look for a freindly battle in Clash Royale
and
To Make this Idea Hopper Proof.
The Joining Members Cannot Leave For 30Days You can Decide who shall Join Your Clan permission is needed
and
if you disagree then simple you
"don't have to" Join that clan and get stuck for 30 days Simple

When I Tried To Build a Clan.
All I Could find was 2 or 3 good Clashers After lvl 2 Clan Perk I quit.

Locking in members for 30 days is am immediate killer for the idea. So they have to become disruptive to make the leader kick them?

Surely, you knew someone who plays clash of clans when you start? Ask if you can join their clan.

[Dvs]

Several things.

What if someone joins this clan. Now, I do not know how much you know about most clans, but the recruiter goes crazy for two hours recruiting to his clan - gets five clashers to join - then goes offline and is never back on again. If I joined xxbeastbodexx in his "Best Clan" I am required to stay for 30 days even if he and the other clashers go inactive? That won't be much fun. I think I will quit too.

Next. You realize how many clans I once joined and immediately got "So are you hot?" Why would I want to stay?

Next - it is hard to build a clan. I will not recommend doing it unless you have hours each day to be in global or you have connections.

No one can join without your "permission" you yourself are the best judge that who do you want in your clan.

The 30 day clause is there because the current system is there and is abused by half the players
Their main motive being request for free troops just to leave after and other reasons.
This is a option which will surely not be used by those players I'm sure of it. That is why this is going to work.

Not Answering to Everyone here. Expect a Reply if You have a Valid Post.

[Roas]

If You like the idea Then reply it Gets More Views.

This idea Will Help Clashers to find
Clanmates and Make sure they Stay.

There Would Be a Start a Clan option in Global Chat. When You Press it
There Would appear a tab Where Clashers Can Join you.
At least 10 Members needed to start a Clan.

So The Tab Remains in Global Chat till u find 9 players in Your Global. How Many will Join Can Be Set 50 will Be Maximum.


If You have played Clash royale It will be the same tab when you look for a freindly battle in Clash Royale

I have, yet I don't remember seeing that feature, then again CR isn't really a game for me, It is too much a Pay2Win game for my taste. (and it is too much of a bully game.)

and
To Make this Idea Hopper Proof.
The Joining Members Cannot Leave For 30Days You can Decide who shall Join Your Clan permission is needed
and
if you disagree then simple you
"don't have to" Join that clan and get stuck for 30 days Simple��

Here I'm guessing, but the 30 days is only for the initialy 10 people you need to start the clan?
I also guess that leaders can kick any of the 9 players that are forced to stay in the clan for those 30 days and that the leader/creator can't leave the clan for those 30 days as well.
So for better and worse you are stuck together. They can be the most annoying players in the world and no one can kick them or do anything about that. (If you want to force them to stay in the clan then it is fair enough that you can't kick them or anything for those 30 days.) Here is a question: "How will you deal with people that doesn't understand boundaries. Like the question Cilakila asked: "Why should a girl stay in a clan that ask if she is hot as some of the first things they ask her?"

I'm also guessing that the 30 days (in prison) isn't for people that joins later, so they might go if the clan isn't what they expected or were promised it to be. So your clan will be as every other clan after the 30 days from the beginning?

When I Tried To Build a Clan.
All I Could find was 2 or 3 good Clashers After lvl 2 Clan Perk I quit.

I use to say "Being a clan leader is really not a job for everyone. There are so many clanleaders that have no clue how to lead a clan and really blame Supercell for their lack of putting in the hours, making the right rules and living by them. Leadership is hard, it is a lot work (A really lot of work and hours of it every day.)"

Here is a link to a great post.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...as-got-tougher

.oO(Here is my question for you: "Why do really you want to be leader of a clan?")

[TheCrumpetMan]

30 days!
The 30 days needs to be lowered Considerable, at least then the idea might not get bashed quite as much

[Dvs]

Although I dont think the idea adds value to the recruiting process, one aspect that did appeal to me was how it would form a bunch of Roach Motels for hoppers. Hoppers go in but they dont come out! Sweet!

😂ok Rwelsh is back

[Dvs]

I have, yet I don't remember seeing that feature, then again CR isn't really a game for me, It is too much a Pay2Win game for my taste. (and it is too much of a bully game.)



Here I'm guessing, but the 30 days is only for the initialy 10 people you need to start the clan?
I also guess that leaders can kick any of the 9 players that are forced to stay in the clan for those 30 days and that the leader/creator can't leave the clan for those 30 days as well.
So for better and worse you are stuck together. They can be the most annoying players in the world and no one can kick them or do anything about that. (If you want to force them to stay in the clan then it is fair enough that you can't kick them or anything for those 30 days.) Here is a question: "How will you deal with people that doesn't understand boundaries. Like the question Cilakila asked: "Why should a girl stay in a clan that ask if she is hot as some of the first things they ask her?"

I'm also guessing that the 30 days (in prison) isn't for people that joins later, so they might go if the clan isn't what they expected or were promised it to be. So your clan will be as every other clan after the 30 days from the beginning?



I use to say "Being a clan leader is really not a job for everyone. There are so many clanleaders that have no clue how to lead a clan and really blame Supercell for their lack of putting in the hours, making the right rules and living by them. Leadership is hard, it is a lot work (A really lot of work and hours of it every day.)"

Here is a link to a great post.
https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...as-got-tougher

.oO(Here is my question for you: "Why do really you want to be leader of a clan?")

OK great so

1) Yeah 30 Day No Leave policy is for the Members which Joined when The Clan Is formed and You can Chat With Your Potential Members and find if they are really serious discuss how the Clan Will be Run find out if they are Immature, Abusive as above stated My Point is It is Manageable.

2)and for your second part of the reply I have a lvl 2 Clan which once reached 7 War Win Streak. Do you still Consider that I dont know how to run a Clan. Its Just No one Joins.

[SMAEL]

OK great so

1) Yeah 30 Day No Leave policy is for the Members which Joined when The Clan Is formed and You can Chat With Your Potential Members and find if they are really serious discuss how the Clan Will be Run find out if they are Immature, Abusive as above stated My Point is It is Manageable.

2)and for your second part of the reply I have a lvl 2 Clan which once reached 7 War Win Streak. Do you still Consider that I dont know how to run a Clan. Its Just No one Joins.

1) you cant find 9 others like that in global on 1 go, IMPOSSIBLE
2)You have lvl 2 clan, that means you are not in the leadership for long, the fact that you had 7 streak doesnt make your clan better or you better leader.