What about sister clans? You couldn't go from one to another for troops or for some chat.
Looks like you have encountered this, but the solution is not changing the way game works, but you trying to solve it on your own.
What about sister clans? You couldn't go from one to another for troops or for some chat.
Looks like you have encountered this, but the solution is not changing the way game works, but you trying to solve it on your own.
"What kind of a monster are you !?" " The Wolverine." Shingen, Wolverine
"You know nothing Socrates. I know that I know nothing." Ygritte, Socrates
"I am the Master and you will obey me." Master
"Nature made me a freak. Man made me a weapon. And God made it last long." Logan
Then let me ask you this why do you need a new clan when you already can war in your 2 or 3 sister clan.Originally Posted by SMAEL
Normally when I see a post with the title, "Best.Idea.is.Here" I am skeptical.
While it is true this feature may control clan hoppers, the main question is why would you want somebody to be forced to stay in a clan they clearly don't want to be in? This will only cause a nuisance to some and I'm positive there will be a handful of players who will try things that could get them kicked out of the clan: rudeness, terrible donation, attacking wrong or not at all in wars. So if kicking is an option to break the 30 days requirement to leave a clan, expect to see people trying everything.
Sub-clans would also come to mind. There are multiple players who have several clans they visit, having a longer period before you can go back to your other clan would also be bothersome to them.
Also, there are players who makes a clan, but then stops playing the game. You would be stuck in an inactive clan.
Firstly Who told you I'm forcing anyone to stay in for 30 days its an option for startup Clans Don't Argue just for the sake of it.
and also this feature is option you don't have to join or no one is forcing u. Rest of your reply is imaginary in which I don't see a problem.
This feature will be used to form a clan with agreement amongst members.
As for your sub Clan problem I have already posted a reply above.
Last edited by Bakunin; May 16th, 2017 at 02:51 PM.
When you post an idea here you should expect feedback both positive and negative. The tone in your responses and not accepting criticism will not help your cause. Name calling of any kind is against forum rules and is certainly not going to help promote your idea. No matter how bad it is. I suggest you read forum rules very carefully before attack anyone else's opinion.
Not directing it solely on you, I'm saying if this was a feature and people that use it will make anyone who joins stuck with them for about a month.
By all means, I would not join a different clan, I've been in the same one for years, but as this is an option for Global, you are bound to find a lot of players who are not as committed to staying in a clan that long.
I posted my previous post before reading that someone else already addressed an issue to this.
Since this is an optional feature that some can use. It probably would be simpler for SuperCell to just keep the current system rather add something that could cause gameplay problems for some.
1)Yeah so they can be careful who to join or even use the feature which will be great according to me.
2)I'm not saying that there isn't a hopper problem and I don't think I will find many who aren't committed because that's how the feature is designed and will be used.
3) Gameplay problems I doubt it. Its an agreement between clashers. You simply can ignore it if you don't want to use it.
and supercell may add it because I think it has its merits.
Last edited by Dvs; May 16th, 2017 at 11:23 AM.
well I wouldn't join a clan where I'm stuck in for 30 days, who would? maybe It would only be 2 days(this would now be reasonable)
No it's not. There's no reasonable minimum time to be forced to stay in a clan. If I join and don't like what I see, I'm gonna leave. I'm not gonna sit on my hands for two days, and if you're gonna try to make me, I'm gonna do everything I can to get kicked out
Though it's abundantly clear by OPs replies that they're not interested in any opinion that contradicts their own, so this is all I'll say on the issue
The ability to create a clan right on global seems redundant. Especially since you apparently need a minimum of ten members to actually start it through global. Good luck with that one. Why would I do that when I can create a clan without this feature and accept as many or as few people as I want? As for the 30 day rule...well, you can see above how I feel about 2 days
When something looks smells and tastes like something you wouldn't want to do any of those with than it probably is that thing.
I'm refering to cabbage ofc.
Posting Permissions
