The perfect Clan Wars, Amazing Idea WITH PICTURES [MUST READ]

[Cade5678]

This has obviously been thought through really well but it just seems to complicated. For example the penalties for losing a clan war etc.

Good idea but maybe a bit too complicated.

Lets make a hypothetical situation

Main clan is having trophy push

Feeder clan wants to help

Feeder battles, loses, 3 time in a row

Since they are banned, they make a new clan and all the members join the new one

Repeat, Main clan is GOD




P.S did anyone notice that lvl 19 who was in crystal??:eek::eek:

Thank for not quoting me :'(

[RomanKing]

Thank for not quoting me :'(

what?

10Chars

[RomanKing]

Making an Alliance extension soon, stay tuned.

[Francauqui]

This is something that they should have in the game but that you make a war of 10 clans. This would help us keep count of our stars in LoC in this month my clan will be participating in LoC

[cmanos1]

what?

10Chars

Do I have permission to use your pictures in another post? Thanks

[cmanos1]

Roman King, I think it's great, except the TH based attacking system, as some THs vary wildly from base to base, so I Saltin and I decided that it should level based, so you attack the person nearest in level. Check out mine in my sig

[TheGreatKing]

Dude this is an awesome idea, I wish this can actually happen!

[JSpong]

This is my first time looking over a clan wars thread, based on the date I assume there are many more threads out there, but alas; I very much approve of a lot of the matchmaking concepts, but let me put in my opinion.

In regards to the actual matchmaking search, it cannot be based on trophies simply because it is not an accurate form of comparing strength and ability. Elite farming clans would destroy some other clan in their trophy range full of players who don't quite completely understand the concept of the game, yet. I VERY much approve of the attack delays, thus negating any chance of gem abuse, however, being offline and shields should not take in effect. ie: Clan full of gemmers all manage several attacks while online, all players buy a two day-week shield. Now this is very extreme, obviously, but I almost guarantee this would happen eventually and it would mean a cheap easy win. I honestly believe the best form of attacking, like I said, is to not have shield or online barriers, but more so based on attacks per x hours. ie: Each player in a clan can do up to 5 attacks per 12 hours, thus making the attacking completely equal. The only advantage in this case would be a slightly more active clan taking the upper hand, but that is quite fair. In regards to the actual clan matchmaking, perhaps on top of the overall trophy range, there should be town hall statistics kept in check, as in clan A with 30 th 10s, 15 th 9s, 5 th 8s cannot attack clan B who have the same amount of trophies with 45 th 7s. Now, of course the accept/decline option takes all of the matchmaking issues into reality, I feel a lot of disinterested clans may waste players times by just declining everything. Once a clan makes a certain decision to war on another, that clan should have to accept within x amount of hours, otherwise the clan will be thrown into war regardless.


Lastly, an option for clans to do several wars if they wish and the ability to turn off wars altogether if the clan approves.

[Saltin]

I just looked at your thread and I can tell that you put a lot of effort into this, so good job! But theres one concern that I see

I dont think match making should be based on TH, even though it seems fair. Just meaning that you if have the same TH lvl doesn't always mean the they are close lvl to you.

I think it wont be fair aganist premature TH's, which are way lower lvl than an average village, so the premmies can be destroyed quite easily

One thing I suggest is to change the system so that you will be matched with someone with the other clan that are the just about the same lvl as you. It will make it more fair IMO, it is what my current clan war idea has right now. Please let me know what you think

Overall this is a great idea and you got my thimbs up +1

[ChiefFirestar]

About the idea. I was reading about the Attack! Button and the find match button and I got confused. Which one sets up the match? I like the pictures though...