The perfect Clan Wars, Amazing Idea WITH PICTURES [MUST READ]

[consoledoctor]

It needs to be a short war 8-24 hours... Are you still able to raid there resources? What about shields or can they just keep attacking your weakest player. Or would you match 1 vs 1, 2 vs 2... Or th based matchmaking, I could just dump trophies and then just destroy 3 star lvl 8s or weaker lvl 9s as they hit the brick wall which is my base... User lvl might be the most relevant way to match people up in these. As a farmer im at 1400-1800 lvl but can hit 2530 (last trophy run). As far as people online you need to be able to attack them. Its a war thus you need to be able to attack something like 5 mins log off like before a mantainacne break, saying your going to be attacked you will be logged off in 5 mins.. People who have bought shields not sure how you handle them?

1. match making?
2. Attacks and shields?
3. Rewards and penalties?
4. Raid loot?
5. Abuse by family clans?
6. Gemmers can they just keep on attacking every 10 second? Back to matchmaking and shields?



lastly great job well thought out.. I agree we need some clan wars just posing a few questions

jacker

Dragon Warriors

Gold farmer switching to a DE farmer...78/250 lvl 9 walls Getting those heroes to 20 plus is a journey AQ10,BQ 9
lvl 102
th lvl 9 December 31st estimated upgrade date to 10
lvl 12 storages please

[RomanKing]

It needs to be a short war 8-24 hours... Are you still able to raid there resources? What about shields or can they just keep attacking your weakest player. Or would you match 1 vs 1, 2 vs 2... Or th based matchmaking, I could just dump trophies and then just destroy 3 star lvl 8s or weaker lvl 9s as they hit the brick wall which is my base... User lvl might be the most relevant way to match people up in these. As a farmer im at 1400-1800 lvl but can hit 2530 (last trophy run). As far as people online you need to be able to attack them. Its a war thus you need to be able to attack something like 5 mins log off like before a mantainacne break, saying your going to be attacked you will be logged off in 5 mins.. People who have bought shields not sure how you handle them?

1. match making?
2. Attacks and shields?
3. Rewards and penalties?
4. Raid loot?
5. Abuse by family clans?
6. Gemmers can they just keep on attacking every 10 second? Back to matchmaking and shields?



lastly great job well thought out.. I agree we need some clan wars just posing a few questions

jacker

Dragon Warriors

Gold farmer switching to a DE farmer...78/250 lvl 9 walls Getting those heroes to 20 plus is a journey AQ10,BQ 9
lvl 102
th lvl 9 December 31st estimated upgrade date to 10
lvl 12 storages please

Matchmaking i did set it up, it is a week for a reason, and i did answer all these questions.

U dont get shielded but once attacked u cant be attacked for another hour.
U cant raid loot u get loot through winning the war
and it may be abused a bit, but it is the best idea out there.
Gemmers cant keep raiding because there is a 12 hour cooldown before u can attack again.

[Xamzibanzai]

Very good and detailed. Not the best images but obviously it's just a first proposal. I cannot see any real problems with it, except
a) will you losing a battle increase the stars of the opponent?
B) how will you find a clam to attack?
C) do you have to attack everyone in the other clan? Or is it a, you can only attack each one once, but it may help to attack lots, of you want to win?

[Eggs]

I love this idea i hope the devs add this!

[Eggs]

This is obviuosly the best idea we have heard yet on clan battles! Everyone wants clan battles, the name suggests clan battles notice its called clash of clans! This is a great thread thumbs up! Devs please add this idea!

[RomanKing]

Very good and detailed. Not the best images but obviously it's just a first proposal. I cannot see any real problems with it, except
a) will you losing a battle increase the stars of the opponent?
B) how will you find a clam to attack?
C) do you have to attack everyone in the other clan? Or is it a, you can only attack each one once, but it may help to attack lots, of you want to win?

alright let me answer these question even though i believe i answered them already.
a) when loosing a star u loose stars, u loose i think 3 or 2 stars if u attack, and if u forfiet without attacking u loose one star.
b) theres a search clan button, simply search a clan. or find on global.
c) u dont have to attack everyone when searching it will a get an opponenet from the other clan that wasnt attacked by a clan member for the past 12 hours.. forfieting doesnt count.

hope i answered ur questions, feel free to ask anything if ur curious.

[Charlie1]

Awesome i dea I love it.

[RomanKing]

Awesome i dea I love it.

Thanks

10Char

[ChiefofLiquidOrder]

great and nice with the pictures and stuff but with the loot bonuses when you get higher you will realize that if you get 1mil a week you will not (still) be able to keep up with upgrades so I say increase for crystal and above so it will inspire more people to push further

[Smithy666]

Yeah would be good.