The perfect Clan Wars, Amazing Idea WITH PICTURES [MUST READ]

[WeatherGuy99]

I don't like the idea of the losing 50k if ur clan losses. What if some ppl don't want to go to war, but the rest of the clan says yes?

[RomanKing]

I don't like the idea of the losing 50k if ur clan losses. What if some ppl don't want to go to war, but the rest of the clan says yes?

those where not solid ideas but there must be some sort of penalty, and if u dont want to go to war, yea u can leave the clan I guess.

[RomanKing]

Huge round of applause...

Thank u, thank u!

[rardriar]

I really like this idea it seems so complete

[Jbdevery]

Biggest thing i don't like is the need to have 40 clan members.

More reasonable, would be not allowing a smaller clan to be at war with a larger clan. But still allowing small clans to battel small clans.

[RomanKing]

Biggest thing i don't like is the need to have 40 clan members.

More reasonable, would be not allowing a smaller clan to be at war with a larger clan. But still allowing small clans to battel small clans.

I dont recommend that, u must have a full functioning clan to be in a war, if we start making alot of small clans, then the idea will be abused

for example, put ur alt in a one man clan and ur main in another, and then make a war, and well get free loot without u ever getting raided, 100% win.

Even though I limited this type of abuse in my idea well what ur saying is making things worse. I put everything for a reason.

[Jbdevery]

My only issue is that I am in a clan of about 20.

The reason is that these are all friends I know who play this game, I enjoy keeping it like that.

I have another friend who has a similar clan, and we kind of but heads and try to say who is better.

This feature would be perfect for us, however, the 40 player minimum limits us, and it would be like nothing changed in the game.


Fully functioning clan is not really a set determination. Yes with more people there are no donations, and you can actually compete in the ranking of clans. But, since there is no actual clan on clan battle, and donations and clan ranking is all a clan is good for, saying that one with 40 is complete, and one with 20 isn't is a bit opinionated.
No offense, but since there is no competing stricture out there for clans, (other than trophies, which works individually), it is hard to even define what a functioning clan is.

20 members who are in a league, and not new should have no issue battling a clan with a similar number of active members.

obviously 1v1 player clans opens it up for abuse, but 20 verses 20?

[ac2023]

Is the thread a dead one?

[Aldo20]

Is the thread a dead one?

i don t want that!this idea is the best one out there lol

[Ince]

Haha.
If all of my members are online.
no one can attack me. Hehe.
Thats too easy to defend our clan stars.