The Better Clan Wars version:
This isnt completely perfect, but if you would like, suggest an idea or find a loophole say it below, and ill add it, all reviews and questions will be answered an appreciated.
Index:
*Matchmaking
*Setup & Time
* Matchmaking:
>
Picking an opponent:
- Search any clan of your choice, there will be an option called “Attack!” on top of the join button. (Join button isn’t functional since you’re in a clan.
- Also, you can request from a clan that is within
1000-3000 trophies of your clan, and you must have a minimum of 40 members in your clan.
If someone is already matched then the Attack! Button will be gray, and telling you that this clan is already matched.
> To participate: (also helps in lowering hoppers)
- If a War began, and you just joined a clan, you will not be able to participate in the current war, and your status will remain NEW, till the end of the week, where a new war begins.
- You must be in a league, if members in a clan are lower trophies then any league, they wont join the battle, but if the amount of people that are league-less are less then 40, your clan wont be able to fight in the battle.
> Leaders and Elders:
- The “Start War” button will appear to leaders and elders only, but only the leader can accept a war. When an elder presses the button, an option shows to the leader in his inbox saying for example “(elder name) has suggested that our clan goes to War with:” and it shows the other clans name. Below that there is an accept and decline button to the invitation. When a leader presses this button though it is sent as a request to the other clan, where the leader of that clan can accept and decline the offer.
- (This option won’t allow the strong attack the weak, as the leader will first check out the clan that is giving the offer and see if it is his clan’s level.)
*
Setup & Time:
> When can you start or join a battle:
- A “War” lasts a week, but in one season a clan only has two times where they can join a battle. A season being two weeks means there are 2 battles in a season. The timeframe where you can join a battle is the first 48 hours of every week. For example, the season just began, in the clan war tab (will talk about later) there is a timer for 24 to 48 hours were in that time you can join a battle. If the timer finishes then you won’t be able to join a battle for the rest of the week. Why is it like this? Well, one it is to have all battles active at the same time, the second reason will be told later.
> Clan tab:
- This is what a lot of people have been waiting for, how will you DO Clan wars, well here the broad explanation. After two leaders accept to battle within that 24 to 48 hour timeframe. The Clan Wars tab will open which is accessible when clicking on your clan castle and opening clan. There are two options already your own clan and the search clan option. Then there will be a third option “Clan Wars”.
The screen before a battle will be empty saying “Your currently not in a War”, and will view the 24 to 48 hours period timer. But when you begin a war, this page has, your clan and the opponent clan viewable on it. It will show 100 players on the screen. There will be 4 large counters 2 counters on top each clan, one will have amount of stars won and the amount of stars lost. (will be explained later).
> Stars:
- Who wins will be put into stars, How do you add to your winning counter and how do you add to your loosing counter. Alright, I planned this clan war version to be trophy based, so we will do it by stars. Win 1 star in a battle, then it gets added 1 star to your clans winning counter, win 2 it adds 2, win 3 it adds 3. How about in the loosing? There are two ways to lose, one forfeiting, attacking and failing. If you forfeit before deploying a troop, then you lose 2 stars. If you lose the battle then you lose 3 stars.
The winning counter will gather all the won stars, and the loosing counter will gather all the lost stars. (it won’t view each player since I think it will take too much resources). The Clan with the most stars wins.
Took me forever to make it. (im not a pro at editing)
> Battles:
- You click the “Search for a match” button that will be on the head of the Clan Wars tab. You can attack un-shielded and offline people only.
- Battles will be TOWNHALL based, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that we have to change the regular raiding system, but when searching here it will get a townhall like yours.
- If you attack someone win or lose or even forfeit, he/ she will be written attacked on the clan war board. If he/she have this, it will stay for 12 hours not allowing him to be attacked again even if unshielded.
- The attack will not be able to attack again after an 12 hour period as well. To balance the war. I know people will complain, but well you cant raid every 30 minutes or so. Maybe make it 6 or 8 hours.
- Replays of Clan War battles, will be put in a separate page then the regular replays.
http://imgur.com/ndgRjkd,CI4Eamv,mIZdpWy,xNAYLd0,GKcb2ux#
* Loot & Leagues:
- This is a very sensitive topic that people say will be abused. I have looked for the best way to DECREASE, but can never completely remove it. Alright, when you attack someone, the available loot takeable will be very low, max 10k gold and elixir, which you don’t take from the storages but from the cc (later decreased from storages). Now people will say, what then clan wars will have no purpose, No, that’s where the league plays in.
- This is for farmers sadly NOT in their favor as it supports a trophy based clan wars, because if it wasn’t it will result in a complete failure. Alright, So what is the relation, the real loot you get is from what I call “League Spoils” It has that in the end of the week, the winner of the battle are the ones that take the Spoils of war. This is a detailed system which I will mention below.
- You must be in a league to join the war. Now this is where it gets interesting. Obviously, I have not added any loot from raids, you cant bet, so where do you get loot, and how is it fair for high trophied players. Alright the winner gets the league spoils, and what is interesting is that, every league gets DIFFERENT LOOT BONUSES. A new page with all the badges will be made showing the amount of loot each member of a clan takes, so in all the higher your badge the more cash you get from winning. Losers get nothing
. But these lootings will be high like a champ gets a mil, a master gets 800k, a crystal gets 500k, a gold gets 250k, a silver gets 100k, and a bronze gets 50k.
- How is this system decrease abuse, everyone says that people will attack each other and take the loot, this way, it will be terribly decreased, as they will have to hold their regular trophies, and wait a week to take in any loot.
> EXTRA: How to not allow family clans, intentionally let another win: a few ideas
§ loosing team will loose 1000 trophies from their average resulting in each member to loose 20 trophies.
§ If a Clan loses 3 times in a row, they won’t be allowed to battle for 2 seasons.
§ 50k will be decreased from each member.
§ EDIT: Builder suspension was just an add-on, and now removed because of negative feedback towards it.
This is a hard subject, but the only solution is having the losing team loose something important.
This is the end of this version, and sorry farmers this isn’t made to help you guys, but make a functional system that bring meaning to trophies and won’t be abused. I’m betting this is the best Idea out there, and it did take me a lot of time to implement, and thinking.
Credits to ZachUVA, since I took some of his Ideas.
Thanks, RomanKing
Stay tuned, for the extension, Clan Wars Alliances.
Originally Posted by fazzat
