Great logic, make it so the "masses" who don't take the time to plan a 3 star, can 3 star someone who spends hours making a base. This game isn't just about attacking you know?Originally Posted by ProfChaos
Great logic, make it so the "masses" who don't take the time to plan a 3 star, can 3 star someone who spends hours making a base. This game isn't just about attacking you know?
Last edited by athill16; March 19th, 2017 at 11:48 PM.
How does bowlers being in the attack change ANYTHING? Witches were just upgrades a couple weeks ago, what about th10 before that? It was fine? So this doesn't hurt th10 in the way that you're suggesting. I literally never heard anyone in any of my clans EVER say they need to buff witches, never did I say that someone HASNT said that, but I guess I'm lying since you know every single thing about my life. And mass miners did the EXACT same thing when they were buffed at th11 as witches do at th9, and they were nerfed soon after, please enlighten me how it's any different since I know nothing about the game 😂😂.
P.S. I've played since 2013 and have over 1k war stars, I think I know something about the game, so don't say childish stuff.
P.P.S https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlXpHOe-TQo
There's a link to the miners as they were, they were nerfed in October. Figured I would show proof since you seem to be the stubborn type..
Last edited by athill16; March 19th, 2017 at 11:47 PM.
What I meant, but better said (thats why you are a professor)
Last edited by NotTheRealPaul; March 20th, 2017 at 12:31 AM.
Bowlers being involved in the attack mean that it is not purely a mass witch attack as you claimed. Arguably, it is a bowler attack with witches as an adjunct. Why are you not calling for bowlers to be nerfed?
TH10 is in need of offence buffs. Witches were marginally viable prior to this latest buff, they are now more usable. Your contention that TH10 offence was fine is not the experience of many TH10 players. I suggest that you talk to your TH10 clanmates and ask them about your opinion that a witch nerf wouldn't hurt them.
I did not say that you were lying regarding not seeing anyone ask for stronger witches, nor did I even imply that I know anything at all about your life. I did say that you being unaware of the outcry following their major nerf last year and the ongoing calls for them to be buffed does indicate a lack of knowledge of the wider game.
You stated that "mass miners 3 starred every single th11" - does that video show "every single" TH11 being 3 starred? No, it does not. There were plenty of attack logs posted to show that mass miners were not an auto 3 star and were defensible with a good layout. To say otherwise is not factually correct.
WRT your "childish stuff" nonsense, there was nothing childish in my post. Your war stars and the length of time that you have been playing are irrelevant. You were still unaware that a buff to level 2 witches would negatively affect TH10s and you stated that mass miners 3 starred "every single th11'". It is not childish to point out the fallacy of those positions.
Last edited by Aspex; March 20th, 2017 at 01:20 AM.
If this is a new strategy it will take more than a couple weeks for SC to determine that something is OP. SC is going to want real data not just 1-2 YouTube videos and a couple players claiming they are.
If you look at the threads how many claim drags or loons need nerfed because they are OP. If SC listened to every individual player they would be changing stats of every troop everyday.
Mass witch attack as in there's a lot of witches, 12 witches is a lot. I even linked a video to someone showing the attack and it had bowlers, so don't lie and say that in lying when you know exactly what I was saying. Also, you really think 5 bowlers in CC means it's mass bowlers? What are you even talking about? 5 bowlers is not a "bowler attack with witches as an adjunct." Okay, I agree, th10 needs offense buffs but don't ruin th9 trying to fix it. After the update, I've only seen people annoyed at the witches because people don't want spamming as a strategy, not knowing that people dont want spamming is having a lack of knowledge of the wider game. And you really took that to be literal? I obviously didn't mean that miners 3 started every single th11 base in existence, don't be ridiculous. Just like this witch slap attack doesn't 3 star 100% of the time, come on now. And if it was easy to make a layout to defend them then that would've meant that they weren't OP and they wouldn't have been nerfed, so saying they were easy to defend against isn't factually correct. We've already had people try to make anti witch bases and nobody has successfully made one yet without exposing itself to another strategy. And again, when did I say changing level 2 witches would NOT effect th10's? I said that I know it would effect them, but I saw th10 3 stars happening with air all of the time before the most recent update, so to say that a th10 NEEDS this witch buff is not right. There are other ways to fix th10 without ruining th9.
Oh I agree, but I'm not one of those whiny 12 year olds who can't build a base. This is literally the first post I've ever made about nerfing troops in my life. But trust me, soon enough this attack will be the new meta in no time. The war we are in that just started today, the other clan used it 5 times in the first hour with different witch variants and our th9's stood no chance.
P.S. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jNOG6eb_TM
Onehive labs just posted about it, so the bigger names are starting to make it well-known. It's just a matter of time trust me
Last edited by athill16; March 20th, 2017 at 01:22 AM.
[Quote = athill16; 9761585] Nunca en mi vida he dicho que debe "traer de vuelta las brujas" y nunca a nadie visto manifestar su deseo de que eran más poderosos ... pero de cualquier manera, en realidad nadie usa dragones en Th9, que no quiere decir que ellos deben hacer OP de modo que usted puede utilizar 10 de ellos y obtener un 3 estrellas, la mayoría de lo hace el tiempo? Se pulen valquirias y que eran demasiado OP y la gente los correo basura, por lo que ellos nerfed, Tan porqué nerfing un problema ahora? Te voy a decir por qué, porque la gente odia tener que usar tiempo y la ejecución de obtener un 3 estrellas, quieren que la manera más fácil posible. [/ Quote]
It depends on the army you carry when you are carrying the witches. And it is clear that the most used attack is the golaloon according to what is seen of municipalities 9 in the CWL
Yes, you did link to a video, but only 8 hours ago. and it was not you who first mentioned the involvement of bowlers (although your second batch of screenshots did show the CC contents). You only supplied partial information whilst calling for a nerf. That, along with your misinformation re "every single" TH11, is not conducive to a rational discussion which is essential when calling for a nerf, especially as you are now saying "this witch slap attack doesn't 3 star 100% of the time", which is not the impression that you have attempted to give up until now.
If you didn't mean that miners 3 starred "every single" th11 why did you say it and then further say that those 3 stars weren't "because of a bad base" when they were due to a base that was vulnerable to mass miners, ergo "a bad base" where miner attacks were concerned. And please do quote where I said that "they were easy to defend against".
Misstating the facts really does not help you. You lied about that so how can you expect anyone to believe you when you say "th9 is literally ruined", "Everybody in the serious war scene wants them nerfed" (there are a lot of forum posters who are in the CWL who haven't mentioned it at all BTW) and "our th9's stood no chance". The latter is particularly telling as you yourself say that you can use layouts that defend against this. That you choose not do so is down to you, your reasoning for not doing so is invalid as building a base to combat one attacking strategies has always opened you up to others.
You cannot say "you know exactly what I was saying", especially when you then say that that is not what you meant. You have just demonstrated why no one should take you at your word or take your post seriously when you admit to lying and exaggerating the facts.
"Also, that's why i said nerf them at th9, so make level 2 witches the same as before, but keep level 3 how they are" and "I don't know why they can't just nerf level 2 witches and solve the problem easily" is not you saying that you knew a nerf to level 2 witches would affect TH10. You were blissfully unaware that TH10 only has level 2 witches until it was pointed out to you.
BTW, OneHive posted this attack 3 days ago: https://forum.supercell.com/showthre...early-any-base.
Lastly, please use the multiquote function. That way you cannot be accused of padding your post count.
The point of the post is & was just because the attack works for elites does lot mean it translates to the a barge player and the average players at below end game play need more options to be able to three star to foster continued interest and keep the majority of players progressing.
As to Perma 9s, or really any for that matter, are worthless. Max ThX waring to collect stars asking to be catered to go make them feel good about their mastery of training levels is ludicrous. If you're interested in more challenging game play upgrade your TH.
Last item of note max TH simply playing for wars don't contribute to the games longevity by spending money. SC should never cater to this crowd at the expense of potential new spenders working their way through the game normally.
Upgrade your TH already...
Posting Permissions
