A quick fix to engineering clans. One that will work!

[bhcool12]

u said lets make this game the way it was meant to be played. This is a stragety game. This is how it should be played.

[NotTheRealPaul]

This would murder rushers. Ive tripled rushed th9s with my th8 mini, and this would just put them at a further disadvantage. There have been better solutions proposed, like nerfednames weight tax. Im sure johnny (if he sees this) can link you to them.

[3StarClasher]

There is a problem with this proposal: The engineering clan still has a way better offense with many opportunities to nuke, so what you get at best is a better chance for a tie. That's not the way this feature was intended to work.

[lonewolf1234]

A adjustment to the matchmaking system so the a base has to have a minimum defence weight to be in war. Say a th10 would have to have th9 defences. If it does not its not included in the war.

It's like a temporary ban on engineered bases from being included in war. For these bases to be in war they need to fix them self's.

Extreme engineered bases are unfair and unfair things have been removed before. It's time to address this issue.

[MarshmellowDude]

#ENGINEEREDBASESARECRUEL
l

[Monkeyhole]

A adjustment to the matchmaking system so the a base has to have a minimum defence weight to be in war. Say a th10 would have to have th9 defences. If it does not its not included in the war.

It's like a temporary ban on engineered bases from being included in war. For these bases to be in war they need to fix them self's.

Extreme engineered bases are unfair and unfair things have been removed before. It's time to address this issue.

So if someone upgrades to ten without maxing everything at th9 they don't get to war? So they skipped a few canons and didn't upgrade their spring traps they can't war? That seems rather extreme.

What happens if they introduced a new defense? Does everyone have to sit out until they max those too? I'd still be sitting out of wars cause my bomb towers are only th9 level.

What about rushed players? They would be completely screwed to the point most would probably quit.

Seems to me your idea only helps those that max everything. Which is what alot of these threads amount too. Maxers trying to get an advantage for themselves and force everyone else to play the way they do.

Just cause you think something is unfair does not mean that it is.

[Jammin232]

I think O.P. meant it only applies to your mirror base not any other base. So for example I am assuming O.P. meant if you base 15 as a th8 and their base 15 is a th9. Then as a th8 you can attack the th9 base and get an extra star for destroying the th, plus the 50 percent bonus. So this allows you to cover your mirror base and still be able to 3 star that base. So if base 15 attacks base 1 he cannot get the extra star for the TH bonus. It has to be the mirror base.

This way if you do have to attack your mirror and it happens to be a 1 th lvl higher than you. you are now able to 3 star that th9 base where normally you could only have 2 starred as a th8 in the past. The fact of the matter is if you do face an engineering clan with a lot of lopsided bases than of course we are going to get into a lot of bases who normally can 3 star their mirror now cannot. Which is why O.P. idea is genius. and I think it will work to balance the engineering clan to get this unfair advantage of mismatching thier th lvls in their favor to create an advantage or visa versa disadvantage in war.

This will cause all those engineering clans and bases to stop twisting the system in their favour and create a war environment that is fair and fun for all.

You said it in this post. People would take advantage of that new rule with their mirror to get extra stars in war without trying very hard.

[Aspex]

Hey are you engineered yourself. Why are you calling this a silly thread? Why are you blaming our clan roster. This has nothing to do with clan and roster and more to do with the exploitation of a war system that has gone mad. Read the threads on the forum. I am assuming you are an engineered clan or an engineered base for saying such a thing. It is pretty obvious. Otherwise you would have added some suggestions or ideas that would be more geared towards helping this engineering problem the clash community is facing. I get it. you enjoy getting the advantage in war. Good for you.

And no, we are not trying to find easier bases. All we want is to make sure when we do face lopsided bases, that our th8s for example do not have to encounter th9s with 4 ads, and 2 lvl 1 xbows plus the extra walls, traps, or what have you. So anyone saying these bases are easier because they are weaker. Not for a th8 with max troops facing 4 ADS, A QUEEN, AND 2 XBOWS. so there is not possible way our th8s can 3 star that base and if you have 5 or more of these lopsided mirror base match ups?

It's a silly thread because it is proposing changes to the game based upon a flawed or incomplete understanding.

It got sillier when you assumed that someone who pointed out why the proposed change was not a good idea has a vested interest (going so far as to say that it is "pretty obvious" that they are engineering - not to a rational person it isn't) rather than them having a better understanding of the issue than you.

As others have pointed out, mirrors are meaningless. A base's map position only shows its defensive strength relative to its own clan, nothing more. It is possible for a TH8 with max troops to 3 star a proper TH9. A TH9 with missing or underleveled defences should be eminently wipeable. That those TH9s have heavily weighted items like x-bows means that they are not that likely to be engineered. It could be possible that your clan ran into a normal mismatch and have decided to blame the bugbear of the day - 9 months ago it would have been modding that was said to be at fault.