Supercell PLEASE find a solution to roster engineering

[xXXCHRISXXx]

Come on man, that answer seems like your hiding something...just saw its a 10v10 with a ten and 9 at the top for you? What about spots 3-9

1 th10, 4 th9, 2 th8, 3 th7. I hide nothing mate, it's a mismatch at the top. The reason is obvious.

[NeverMor3]

I used to ask supercell for things like this, then I cam to realize they don't care. What was the fix? Engineer our roster. Nobody is doing anything in war you can't duplicate, quit whining and start building.

[Redviper42]

1 th10, 4 th9, 2 th8, 3 th7. I hide nothing mate, it's a mismatch at the top. The reason is obvious.

And their team? Not saying you are hiding just want to get the full picture here

[xXXCHRISXXx]

And their team? Not saying you are hiding just want to get the full picture here

1 th11, 1 th10, 4th9, 1 th8, 1 th6, 2 scrub th3 with nothing unlocked other than barbs on one and barch on the other.

[Lunaticfringe]

As the title suggest, please do something about roster engineering. There should be no reason why th3 are allowed to be included in a war lineup consisting of th10 and 11. This drops their entire clan weight making for very uneven matches at the top. IMO, anything below th7 shouldn't be allowed to war. Yeah I'll probably receive some flak for that but it's my opinion. There should be no reason an account like this is even allowed to participate in wars.

Disagree, fairly strongly.

This is a throw-away, both in attack and defense. Unless you are doing the same, they enemy clan is giving up two potential 3* attacks and giving up a super easy 3*. Some other TH has to attack down to cover for this infant TH and giving up a mindless 3*

I have no problem with this nowadays, as the drawbacks are very significant

Also, they need to adjust the system, to really put a weight focus on the top 50% of bases. The lower 50% weight bases don't really make a difference. You get 2 attacks and the top 50% can cover all the bases. Do you know any clan that has a REAL TH3-6 in war along with maxed out TH11s lol??

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe, right now, that the MM does ~exactly that

[Billius]

I'm reluctant to have too many clan or war rules in the game but I am going to come down on the side of eliminating some of these blatant situations like a TH3 in a TH11 war.
It adds no real value to the war competitiveness and makes matchmaking more of a farce.

[Krsatjhook]

So for a clan like mine where we don't have 10 people to war what do you suggest we do if SC implements this? I have my th3 and th5 accounts as fillers SO WE CAN WAR WITH FEWER PEOPLE. If SC makes this impossible, we couldn't War. Recruiting these days is near impossible with most people being trolls or hoppers. We're just a chill drama free clan nothing special so not sure why there's hate.

If what you are saying is true, then why not develop the bases at the bottom? And as far as the hate goes from other people? You blasted op in your very first resonse. And you you blast people all of the time. I've only been active in the forums for a month or two and I see your posts everywhere and you're blasting people al the time. Karma. You get what you give.

[Krsatjhook]

I think the rub is the TH level. In my clan we normally do 15v15 or 20v20. Sometimes we only have 13 available for war (or 17, etc.). I could put in the TH9s who have a hero down or who are taking a break, OR, I could put in my TH3 accounts. Well right now the answer is easy--put the TH3s in since it gives us a better chance of winning.

I know exactly what I'm doing when I put them in--I'm trying to game the system. It's not a recruiting issue.

At least spidy's honest about it. Much appreciated.

[Redviper42]

1 th11, 1 th10, 4th9, 1 th8, 1 th6, 2 scrub th3 with nothing unlocked other than barbs on one and barch on the other.

Its sounds like a pretty bad match assuming there are no .5s in there. The war is still winable...but i have my doubts on if this clan did this on purpose. Based on the fact that its a ten man war, they may have just created filler accounts to be able to war. Far different from like a 30 v30 or something. Its still doable. Everyone gets mismatches.

[xXXCHRISXXx]

Everyone gets mismatches.

I completely agree, however, if no one brings attention to the problem how is Supercell supposed to know it exist, much less attempt to correct the issue.