Tree and Bushes come to life as defensive troops!

[artmo]

Why?? Pls no.....for me it just dosnt feel right, what logic makes trees and bushes attack? With this there would be no free gems cuz nobody would remove their obstacles, and defenses would be too complicated!

Its an original idea... Sure, but its dosnt mean its a good idea...

Haha... I also feel like that the first time... Clash of clans logic... Not dora's logic... Lol... But I like the idea tho...

[JakeTheClasher]

Maybe this could be in a Halloween update? Dark Forest troops?

This guy should work at supercell! That is an awesome idea. And I think obstacles coming to life would be a cool feature, but I think it should be for a holiday or one week thing otherwise attacking may get too hard.

[Noturbbor]

I kinda think it fits in pretty good. I'm mean we are dealing with magic, spells and raising people from the dead right? Ha ha. Plus it has a good risk reward to it. Possible gems vs extra hidden troops.

[Emanstr]

[QUOTE=Noturbbor;781915]I kinda think it fits in pretty good. I'm mean we are dealing with magic, spells and raising people from the dead right? Ha ha. Plus it has a good risk reward to it. Possible gems vs extra hidden troops.[/QUOTE]
That was added just now :/
this is just so wrong i want to laugh but it just feels so sad that nobody realizes it (
noobs would just have a bonus Defense that are no different from high level players, horray for newbies and boo for balance
Troop targeting would be too crazy.
Giving this much effort for your trees supercell could have first added elder positions or new troops (the important stuff)
and finally HOW WILL PEOPLE START IN LEVEL 1 WITH LEVEL 1 TROOPS AND A FOREST OF DEFENSIVE BUILDINGS! ARE YOU GONNA REMOVE THAT AND REMOVE THE STRATIGICAL FUN IN PLACING YOUR BUILDINGS AT THE START OF THE GAME? Cmon ppl.... :/

[Emanstr]

I just wanted too add... Its not cool, attacking trees are not cool, why the f would they be cool??!! Fuuuuuuuuuuuuu! Hahaha

[Noturbbor]

Ok so we see one person doesn't like it. As for balancing i don't see how this is any different than bombs or spring traps. They can't be upgraded. Same for all players. Maybe some people don't like bombs or traps. Don't like don't use. Doesn't have to be a noob thing either. Could be unlocked at a certain town hall level. Plus it's only a few. Not like you can use it on every single plant. That would be unfair hence the limit. Plus people choosing this instead of cutting them down for gems sounds like a win for Supercell too.

[Noturbbor]

By the way thanks for all the responses and feedback(good or bad). It's cool to see how people respond or think.

[Grokey]

Why?? Pls no.....for me it just dosnt feel right, what logic makes trees and bushes attack? With this there would be no free gems cuz nobody would remove their obstacles, and defenses would be too complicated!

Its an original idea... Sure, but its dosnt mean its a good idea...

Logic is that they use magic...same as wizards, witches, pekkas.

Good, original idea.

[cancan460]

Ok so we see one person doesn't like it. As for balancing i don't see how this is any different than bombs or spring traps. They can't be upgraded. Same for all players. Maybe some people don't like bombs or traps. Don't like don't use. Doesn't have to be a noob thing either. Could be unlocked at a certain town hall level. Plus it's only a few. Not like you can use it on every single plant. That would be unfair hence the limit. Plus people choosing this instead of cutting them down for gems sounds like a win for Supercell too.

Example situation:
I'm a newbie and just started with about 50 obstacles, someone just attacked me and deployed like 50 archers. The archers barely even got through the obstacles and got pummeled by the defenses right away.
see where I'm going?
This would only be balanced if the living trees were there just for fun, did 0 damage and didn't have to be killed/ didn't distract troops.

[RomanKing]

I believe that not all obstacles should live, only a maximum of 3 to 5 at one time.