Shield after you successfully defend an attack.

[TRsuperstar]

When your base is attacked by a complete or near complete complement of troops and they are unsuccessful (ie you successfully defend your base), I believe you should receive at least an 8 hour shield. The attacks will often happen while you sleep. The first attack sets off your traps and empties your clan castle AND they get loot. Then, you are often attacked again, right after (and still sleeping), as the new attacker knows you have been recently attacked by the residual troop gravestones. The next attack comes in and destroys the base and takes EVEN MORE loot, as there are no traps or clan castle troops. This is why you should gain a shield following the first attack.

[WernerDerChamp]

I would suggest giving a 1 hour VG if two of these conditions are met:

• A Level 15+ hero dies (GW at Level 10+)
• Clan Castle was full, and got completely lured and killed
• At least 1 X-Bow, Inferno or the EA has less than 40% ammo
• Rearming traps >= 10k Gold

This will give your heroes time to heal and you some time to come back and rearm everything

[MisterOz]

29%, full army deployed and completely killed. No shield. C'mon... surely my base wrecking an entire army is worth more than a guard? Punish me for maxing my base, having such an awesome hard base or being attacked by bad attackers?

I understand the percentage thing before when we had sniping, but now there is an army component involved as well, I don't see why it still needs to be a destruction percentage when it all hinges on the army numbers deployed.

Why can't it be an either or shield... shield is given if either your base receives 30% destruction OR attacker uses 50% or more of their army space.