Engineered clan again !!

[Noctaire]

Unless I missed it, The OP never offered any evidence of this engineered clan or how they were defeated, and he vanished on his own thread. Looks like more trolling to me.

Althoug I agree something needs to be done to address the roster engineering, I really hope SC isn't listening to all these players who blame their lack of offensive capabilities and attacking skills on engineering by their opponents....

[Night Crawler]

really, i think the only absolute advantage engineered bases have are the psychological advantage to weaker players

I disagree, there is a huge advantage if it's unbalanced and the "lopsided" clan knows how to attack, in my example above, we would have surely lost the war if they knew how to attack. Because we were definitely outgunned by a long ways, and if a "lopsided" player with his max troops ie: miners, cannot 3* a max TH9 well then imo he really needs to practice or take up a different game.

[TheFallenDragon]

Unless I missed it, The OP never offered any evidence of this engineered clan or how they were defeated, and he vanished on his own thread. Looks like more trolling to me.

Althoug I agree something needs to be done to address the roster engineering, I really hope SC isn't listening to all these players who blame their lack of offensive capabilities and attacking skills on engineering by their opponents....

roster engineering is easily fixed. just make the top half or so be near perfectly matched

[bryanw1995]

This^^


It's happening so often we only go to war once a week. Th10 to 8 no fillers continually matching 3+ th11s and a 10 sitting as a 8.

Every single war? Really? What size wars are you running? I'm in a 100% th8-10 clan with a solid w/l record, we typically war with ~ 40% th10, 40% th9 and 20% th8, always either 15v15 or 20v20. We actually have no fillers at all allowed in the clan. We rarely see even one th11, and only once can I recall seeing 2 th11 on opponent side.

I barely do, but occasuonally when people throw around to much anti engineering bias or insults i get sucked back in. Expecially since it seams the mob without missing a beat stepped onto .5 bases. Things got better because the anti engineers won and stopped there capaign of crying and insults, and even after winning, they back still complaining on the forum, and insulting.

Don't get too worked up about it, nobody came into this thread planning to attack you. And, as much as you like the game, you'll quickly attack to whatever the new meta ends up being for clan wars post-patch.

[TheFallenDragon]

I disagree, there is a huge advantage if it's unbalanced and the "lopsided" clan knows how to attack, in my example above, we would have surely lost the war if they knew how to attack. Because we were definitely outgunned by a long ways, and if a "lopsided" player with his max troops ie: miners, cannot 3* a max TH9 well then imo he really needs to practice or take up a different game.

i mean yeah. but by absolute i mean that they have the advantage every war and almost always win due to solely having engineered bases

[TheFallenDragon]

Every single war? Really? What size wars are you running? I'm in a 100% th8-10 clan with a solid w/l record, we typically war with ~ 40% th10, 40% th9 and 20% th8, always either 15v15 or 20v20. We actually have no fillers at all allowed in the clan. We rarely see even one th11, and only once can I recall seeing 2 th11 on opponent side.

maybe he saw a mighty engineered th11 with L3+ drags.

[cnaf]

roster engineering is easily fixed. just make the top half or so be near perfectly matched

That wouldn't solve the 30K weighted TH11s with 40/40/20 sitting down with the TH9s.

[TheFallenDragon]

That wouldn't solve the 30K weighted TH11s with 40/40/20 sitting down with the TH9s.

30K weighting as th9s? arent th9s 68K?

but anyways thats a seperate issue that should also be adressed. roster engineering i consider more as clans that put in low level fillers to lower weight and force a mismatch up top.

[cnaf]

30K weighting as th9s? arent th9s 68K?

but anyways thats a seperate issue that should also be adressed. roster engineering i consider more as clans that put in low level fillers to lower weight and force a mismatch up top.

Yes, my mind is a little preoccupied atm. We don't run lower than TH9s, so that's were they sit when we see them.

And yeah, roster engineering certainly what you said. Maxers love to roster engineer. I'm off in that far away place, trying to figure out how to get a triple on a max TH11 war base.

[TheFallenDragon]

Yes, my mind is a little preoccupied atm. We don't run lower than TH9s, so that's were they sit when we see them.

And yeah, roster engineering certainly what you said. Maxers love to roster engineer. I'm off in that far away place, trying to figure out how to get a triple on a max TH11 war base.

its easy! just spam miners and drop heal spells duh!