Worst War Matchup In History! .5 Gone Wild!

[KhalWarAngels]

Also, feel free to follow the link it my signature. It's quite relevant.

[Lunaticfringe]

I'll just go with your top line, after the first top 7 bases nothing else really matters in any war, all he had to do was tell us what the first bases consisted of and we all know the outcome of the war. People that do this to create an advantage to make themselves unbeatable are as bad as modders. Same mentality that says I'll do anything not to lose. Oh well I seem to have forgotten this is the generation that just presses reset if they are losing in a game and returns to checkpoint.

No, it's actually quite accurate.

See below

Yeah, except Matchmaking looks at clans as a whole.

Thank you sir

[NotTheRealPaul]

Solution
4) Accept that you chose to upgrade defences without considering war.

.5 bases are much more difficult to farm with. You chose to favor farming over war, they chose to favor war over farming. Personal CHOICE. You had the same opportunity but are now complaining because it doesn't suit you perfectly? There aren't nearly as many engineered clans as regular farming orientated clans. Just move on

I farmed fine as an 8.5, and fine as a full th9. if anything, I defended better because weaker people would attack me. Although, I didn't pay attention that much. I don't see xbows as that big of a help on defense as weaker people tend to avoid them.

[tysoebrules]

Supercell needs to do something about .5 bases, specifically permanent .5 bases who refuse to upgrade defenses so they get an unfair advantage in war. This current war against a Chinese clan is absurd, they have 7 town hall 11's and we have 0! Not only do they have 7 town hall 11's to our 0, they are on a 15 win streak! How does a clan on a 15 win streak get such a heavy mismatch in THIER favor? Our war is 30 vs 30.

Our #1 is a town hall 10 with a war weight of 82,000.
Their #1 is a maxed town hall 11 with all maxed defenses (eagle artillery, xbows, infernos), maxed heroes and troops.

Their 2-7 are all town hall 11's with wardens, nearly maxed heroes and high offense.
Our 2-7 are weak town hall 10's with average offense.

Their 1-7 will easily 3 star our 1-14. Our bases have no chance to do the same to them.

My maxed town hall 11 wars with another clan, and guess what? The wars in that clan are the same, nothing but defenseless bases and .5 bases on the enemy team! Supercell, is this how you intended wars to be? Whoever has the most defenseless and .5 bases wins the war?

Solutions:

1) Add weight to town hall so defenseless bases no longer work.

2) After a month at a new town hall the war weight will automatically go up as if all new defenses were built. A month is long enough to upgrade offense. Permanent .5 bases are ruining clan wars.

3) Add weight to offense, by lowering the weight of offense you ENCOURAGE defenseless and .5 bases.

Your match up will probably be quite equal in terms of war weight values. They just have much stronger offence for their top guys as they will have engineered their matches that way.

I'd join them if I were you. Get a .5 mini

[LazyGiraffe]

Yeah, except Matchmaking looks at clans as a whole.

that's why is flawed

[Obamalix]

Where were you critics of .5 before SC tweeked the defensive weights of walls and TH specific defences... Was it allright then or did you also complain at that time ? Lets take a trip back in time... There were just as many threads about mismatches back then.. only they were of the kind .. "our opponent TH10's all have IT's... only one of ours have IT's - thats totally unfair" "our opponent has maxed walls... none of our bases have maxed walls - it's unfair, we don't stand a chance" etc.

Fact is, that no matter how SC try to balance offence and defence it is imposible to match a lopsided base (in either direction) to a balanced base without one of the sides claiming an unfair match. Should the MM start matching at base level rather than clan level, the searches would be endless like the clouds in legend leagues - who wants that ?

[eskado]

Yet another useless complain thread. We're not getting any real betterment until we get a new devs team that actually knows and play the game.

[twinblade123]

Yeah. You're 1-8 are heavily upgraded defensively. Change your LU

[AFrostyBlaze]

weird my clan does 40s and we never come across this type of scenario we also limit our searches to be under an hour.

we do have a bunch of low ths to balance the top out and try and get more even for the 9s

wouldn't it make more sense to add weight to the spell factory and research lab instead of the townhall

[BLM]

Supercell needs to do something about .5 bases, specifically permanent .5 bases who refuse to upgrade defenses so they get an unfair advantage in war. This current war against a Chinese clan is absurd, they have 7 town hall 11's and we have 0! Not only do they have 7 town hall 11's to our 0, they are on a 15 win streak! How does a clan on a 15 win streak get such a heavy mismatch in THIER favor? Our war is 30 vs 30.

Our #1 is a town hall 10 with a war weight of 82,000.
Their #1 is a maxed town hall 11 with all maxed defenses (eagle artillery, xbows, infernos), maxed heroes and troops.

Their 2-7 are all town hall 11's with wardens, nearly maxed heroes and high offense.
Our 2-7 are weak town hall 10's with average offense.

Their 1-7 will easily 3 star our 1-14. Our bases have no chance to do the same to them.

My maxed town hall 11 wars with another clan, and guess what? The wars in that clan are the same, nothing but defenseless bases and .5 bases on the enemy team! Supercell, is this how you intended wars to be? Whoever has the most defenseless and .5 bases wins the war?

Solutions:

1) Add weight to town hall so defenseless bases no longer work.

2) After a month at a new town hall the war weight will automatically go up as if all new defenses were built. A month is long enough to upgrade offense. Permanent .5 bases are ruining clan wars.

3) Add weight to offense, by lowering the weight of offense you ENCOURAGE defenseless and .5 bases.

It's probably your th lvl spread. So if you have th10s, th9s and th8s do not put anything in war smaller than a th8. Only use a spread of 3 th lvls in war and you won't match bad.