A little venting

[smokenbooze1]

Disclaimer : Just my opinion on how it works

1) Joe the clasher is a th9 who has 3700 trophies he decides to attack.
2) Joe has been nexting all the players in his league due to his number of trophies there are less available th9s and he doesnt wanna lose against a th10+.
3) 200 nexts later joe finds a th9 in master 1 who is 700 cups lower then him he feels dejected and lost but he has to attack him for 5 trophies.

- if joe were a th10 or th11 he would have attacked any of the bases in the multi mm queue that he nexted hiwever since the search algorithim that matches town halls to similar lvl does not apply in champ + he has to next his way all the way down 700 trophies worth of bases to you.
-As you go higher there are less bases thats why u see so many more poor trophy offers.
- Supercell cant force people to push so this will inevitably occur until they come up with a solution howver due to the rampant cheating, clan war issues and actual game development this has taken a back seat for far to long. Perhaps with the octopus we will see improvements here.
- there is no value in complaining abt where people attack you from since theres no way to identify there location beyond there clan location (my clan is set to a random location that i dont live in)

[Tiler]

Okay, so I'm only going to post here once, seeing as none of my points were answered in your last thread and I'm 70% sure you're trolling at this point...

1) More trophies does not mean a stronger base. They would've hit you just as hard if they were at or below your league, so I really don't understand the hangup with their league. They got there by attacking a lot. And they'd like to go higher, but they're being offered bases in your league. They're not happy about that

2) Shorter shields is a terrible idea. 12 hours is good, I don't want a lame 6 hour shield or I'll get walloped in the middle of the night without being able to collect. You're asking to directly punish players for playing the game at a high level. You want to actively discourage trophy pushing, and that's ludicrous.

3) If the outcome for your base doesn't matter to you, then why are you complaining about it? Who cares how many trophies your attacker has? Their loot bonus doesn't come out of your storage, and the time they spent searching for ANY base to attack didn't come out of your day.

[vlix]

So, i'll ask this to OP,
Would you rather get attacked by 500 cups above you, lose all resources and -6 cups.
Or would you rather get attacked by 500 cups below you, lose all resources and -34 cups?

[bredin]

Dear OP, ive read your long posts, and I still cannot work out WHY it bothers you?

You said its unfair, but not why its unfair.

Others have given you the mechanics of WHY what youve observed happens, but you have not said WHY that is unfair. Nor does it look like youve considered the main whine about multiplayer: Clouds.

What effect do you think reducing the cup range of higher leagues would have on the main complaint of said higher leagues?

Hint: It will make them much much worse.

[bigdogdigs]

I'll be honest all this just gave me headache

[ElectroWizzard]

@ElfLiya : Go away troll! Shoo! Shoo!

@ElectroWizzard : I'm whatever you wish, just don't misspell my name.

@ds276 : Finally someone that finally sticks to the issue and doesn't bring pushing for instance into the discussion. I tip my hat to you sir.

I'm sure that ElfLiya doesn't need my help, but she is far from trolling by pointing out that in fact you have breached the forum rules. I rather think that they were trying to be helpful.

So, by quoting you're signature you have chosen to look past my valid point, and question. Thanks for a two way conversation.

You're only concerned with this if YOU are the person being attacked, it is perfectly fine for YOU to attack someone else who is 700 cups below you.

Pushing is a relevant part of this discussion, because, even though you claim to not care about the cups, the changes you are suggesting will effect those who do.

Push up to champs, not only will you get a better loot bonus, you will see the other side of this coin.

[Farrow]

Wait so how is someone attacking you from above actually hurting you?

I read your post but I don't get exactly how someone attacking you from higher up is hurting you more than someone raiding you from the same league.

If anything you made out for the better and the other attack should be annoyed to indifferent depending on if they are pushing or farming.

I don't get what there is to complain about or how SC gave people in higher trophies an advantage over others.

[Aaronjs]

I don't even understand what the OP is complaining about. Why is it unfair that a player in a much higher league can attack you?

[cezarica]

@ElectroWizzard : I'm seriously trying to be a nice person and keep the discussion at a acceptable level, but with people pushing all the buttons and picking things out of context isn't quite helping man. Cut me some slack!

No, I don't like the system favoring the player with more cups and screwing the player with less, be it I'm the attacker (the one getting the benefit out of this) or the defender (getting screwed by the system). I'm not going to lie that I would attack anyone that has loot cos then I would be a hypocrite and I'm anything but that.

[AxsMan]

I'm currently pushing my th11 in a (probably doomed) attempt to reach legend. I get matched against mostly maxxed th11s (which is fair enough) and the odd th10 (yippee! :-) ) I don't care what league they are in, I only care how many cups they are worth, and to a lesser extent, will I at least break even on the attack. Actually since I raid bowlers, have filled my de stores and have nothing left to spend de on, I dont really care about the loot at all.

so who would I rather hit - a player in a lower league with 5 cups on offer, or a legend offering me 20? You decide lol!

op makes no sense, just comes across as xenophobic to me.