Stop those hoppers!

[phantomyoda13]

Recently, after creating a clan, it has very suddenly come to my attention that I CAN'T STAND CLAN HOPPERS! I think it'd be a great idea to implement a system that allows a buffer between joining a new clan. In other words, let's say I join a clan, and then suddenly leave after getting troops and trolling. I should have to wait 24 or like 48 hours to join another clan. That way hoppers can't just be hopping all over the place. What do you think?

[vovy340]

Terrible Idea. I hop around friends clan to help them out I wouldn't like to not be able to enter my clan again

[phantomyoda13]

Terrible Idea. I hop around friends clan to help them out I wouldn't like to not be able to enter my clan again

I don't see why it'd be hard to have them ALL join one clan. Or you could pick the one you want to stay in. And also, something like this isn't supposed to fix EVERYTHING. Right now, the big problem is clan hoppers, and that needs to be dealt with before we figure out how to help the small group of people like you who like to "hop to help".

[vovy340]

There should be a ban from clan button. That would stop them

[phantomyoda13]

There should be a ban from clan button. That would stop them

There are thousands of players on clash of clans. Clans can't ban EVERY SINGLE clan hopper that comes by. There will always be new ones.

[yoshispark7]

My solution is if they request when they just join, they are guaranteed hopper.

[Cjdolan]

Solution ideas:
1) if you were in a clan for 10 minutes, requested, and left, your troops turn against you in battle/ on defenses. People won't take and leave.

2) clan castle gets destroyed every time you leave a clan and you have to pay to rebuild it. Price and time goes up by CC level, with the longest time being 6 hours.

3) if you take from a clan and leave without donating, any one person in that clan has the option to "revenge" you. Not technically a revenge, but you have the attack button available for when the person is offline with no shield.

All three of these will definitely deter hopping, but none will be implemented.

[Barjbike]

Recently, after creating a clan, it has very suddenly come to my attention that I CAN'T STAND CLAN HOPPERS! I think it'd be a great idea to implement a system that allows a buffer between joining a new clan. In other words, let's say I join a clan, and then suddenly leave after getting troops and trolling. I should have to wait 24 or like 48 hours to join another clan. That way hoppers can't just be hopping all over the place. What do you think?

I agree, in the early days that I was leader we had tons of hoppers. Now we have no hoppers.. . I agree perhaps a 30 minute wait or an hour. Or perhaps their could be a function that can tell if people have hopped clans before or something

[Barjbike]

Solution ideas:
1) if you were in a clan for 10 minutes, requested, and left, your troops turn against you in battle/ on defenses. People won't take and leave.

2) clan castle gets destroyed every time you leave a clan and you have to pay to rebuild it. Price and time goes up by CC level, with the longest time being 6 hours.

3) if you take from a clan and leave without donating, any one person in that clan has the option to "revenge" you. Not technically a revenge, but you have the attack button available for when the person is offline with no shield.

All three of these will definitely deter hopping, but none will be implemented.

Options 1 and 3 would be fine

[Emanstr]

* History button on clan app - see stats: Last x clans, time in, donations given/received, kicked/left, etc

This way you could immediately see if the person joining is a hopper
what do you guys think? ��