Costing gold to join a clan

[yoshispark7]

Yoshi, thats a good point but the idea is that the clan leader is able to choose the amount of gold required. If your clan doesnt like that idea, then your clan leader can simply put the amount of gold required to join at free. But then u have to consider the matter of hoppers, so u might want to put the gold requirement at a low lvl but still above zero.

Where does the gold go? Nowhere
if it goes to member and leader, that trading resource and it ruled out, so it a lose lose for us and supercell

[Hamletking]

Really? Thats Alot for joining a clan What if you've started of a clan and you want people to join? would they join if it costs 40k? for one person!

[Rager]

Silly idea. Have you even thought about how much gold it would cost clans that have a family and people frequently go to other clans in the family to tell someone something.

[SirPsycho]

Silly idea. Have you even thought about how much gold it would cost clans that have a family and people frequently go to other clans in the family to tell someone something.

People who have sister clans or feeder clans can afford the premium. Now its not supposed to benefit everyone. But it does keep stability and it will eliminate people from jumping around. If the developers what to introduce a system where they can link sister clans together, then that should help ppl withsister clans. But this idea is for the greater good .. No one travels for free.

this idea isnt only about hoppers .. Its to encourage all members to be active, cause if theyre not, they will get kicked out. And will have to pay to find a new clan. And if theyre not active in the new clan, they will get kicked out aand again they will pay again for a new one. ...

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

[fearlesskiller]

Just for your information, 100,000k is not much.

100,000k is alot
100,000k=100,000,000

[RomanKing]

​i see the best wayto stop hoppers is that when someone leaves with recieved troops they simply dissappear... best idea and canthurt any family clans

[Willdrewest]

Maybe you could refund the cost if the player donates troops inside the clan.

[MoHandles]

People who have sister clans or feeder clans can afford the premium. Now its not supposed to benefit everyone. But it does keep stability and it will eliminate people from jumping around. If the developers what to introduce a system where they can link sister clans together, then that should help ppl withsister clans. But this idea is for the greater good .. No one travels for free.

this idea isnt only about hoppers .. Its to encourage all members to be active, cause if theyre not, they will get kicked out. And will have to pay to find a new clan. And if theyre not active in the new clan, they will get kicked out aand again they will pay again for a new one. ...

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

I don't think you realize what you're suggesting. You say a town hall 9, which I am, would have to pay 75k gold. Well, if I wanted to switch between all of the clans I am a part of in a short period of time, that adds up to 225k gold. Just to switch clans. Think about that. The invite only setting is there for a reason. If you need stability, then use it. I will not be paying 225k gold to visit my clanmates, even if I can afford it.

[MoHandles]

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

Au contraire sir. This will keep clan members in constant fear, a fear of being eliminated from their clan and having to find a new one. And I guarantee you, there will be clans which make people pay the fee, only to kick the person right afterwards, just for laughs. I don't think you fully comprehend the consequences of this idea, and you need to step back and look at it from a wider perspective. You consider yourself to be suggesting for the greater good of CoC, yet this feature will only benefit the new up and coming clans, and will greatly hurt the already established families.

[TheRulingEmperor]

Au contraire sir. This will keep clan members in constant fear, a fear of being eliminated from their clan and having to find a new one. And I guarantee you, there will be clans which make people pay the fee, only to kick the person right afterwards, just for laughs. I don't think you fully comprehend the consequences of this idea, and you need to step back and look at it from a wider perspective. You consider yourself to be suggesting for the greater good of CoC, yet this feature will only benefit the new up and coming clans, and will greatly hurt the already established families.

I like it. DOWN WITH THE ESTABLISHMENT! ON WITH THE NEW AND RADICAL!!!!

nah..it will benefit both new and old clans