Costing gold to join a clan

[dahimi]

That's a good idea!

How about..
• the price isn't fixed and can be controlled by the clan leader
• you must stay a certain amount of hours or days to not pay
• the money still goes to nowhere UNTIL the clan village has been fully implemented to the game where the money will rest to the clan village's coffers

No. People should not be held hostage because they chose to join a clan where they are not a good fit.

I know you're in love with this idea, but it is not the way to stop hoppers. It creates more problems then it solves.

You want to fix hoppers? Create a leader configurable option that indicates how much time a person needs to spend in the clan before they can request.

[Conn0r33]

I think the leader should set the amount to join the clan, and the money should be divided between members maybe just leaders and elders or maybe just to everyone

[DuckDuckDuck]

Instead of the set limit, we could have it so the leader decides the amount. Like someone said before, if you don't like the cost you could set the cost to zero. The cost would add prestige and would ultimately help stop hoppers. And to fix the problem of visiting feeders, I think that a new type of clan could be added called an empire. In the empire you could put all your clans in it and you only have to pay once (when first entering the empire) so you could join all your feeders for free.

[CorbinMC]

I am part of a VERY loyal family of clans. In our clans, elders need to move between them. If this costed us gold, we would go broke. Leave it the way it is. Be more choosy about who you let in if you have a problem with hoppers. If someone take 5 troops from you, suck it up and make more.

Yeah, just don't donate drags and pekkas to newbies and your problem is solved.

[Derrickfn]

You need to change your question. Yes Clan hopping is a problem, but No I do not think paying to get in a clan as the solution. I'm part of a six clan clan family and move around the clans quite a bit.

We actually boot people that join the clan then immediately request troops. I think internal clan policy can handle the hoping issue. we don't have to create a law for everything. I'm a high level player and often join little clans to supply those new clans some much need troop relief. Everyone love maxed troops.

Derrick

[BUDDERPEGUIN43]

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

Yoshi, thats a good point but the idea is that the clan leader is able to choose the amount of gold required. If your clan doesnt like that idea, then your clan leader can simply put the amount of gold required to join at free. But then u have to consider the matter of hoppers, so u might want to put the gold requirement at a low lvl but still above zero.

[BUDDERPEGUIN43]

(Ignore This) i accidently posted this twice so im editing it lol.

[BUDDERPEGUIN43]

New Clan Members are not allowed to request until they donate.

[Kelemvour]

A few simple ideas that would work to stop clan hoppers.

1: if you leave a clan you must wait X amount of days before joining a clan.

2: It costs X amount of gems to join a clan.

3: Clan admin/elders have ability to add user names to "Exile" list so hoppers can never rejoin.

[yoshispark7]

A few simple ideas that would work to stop clan hoppers.

1: if you leave a clan you must wait X amount of days before joining a clan.

2: It costs X amount of gems to join a clan.

3: Clan admin/elders have ability to add user names to "Exile" list so hoppers can never rejoin.

1: as long as it not long

2: are you seriously paying gem!that dumb

3: Sorry blacklist is in the sticky, but not ruled out