Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[Smarty1]

So after 1 "scouting" attack? All the troops are out and traps are exposed.

[gazheaven]

Maybe there were more people modding than any of us ever thought. For SC to legitimise this bullsheet they must have been hit hard by them leaving the game? But it basically takes war away from everyone who isn't a hardcore no lifer.

[bbdoc]

i think 48 hours and its perfect....
24 means people can still practice once war starts

Yep, a cooldown is a must

Don't SC realize how much pressure this will put on CW ? People will start bashing each other on every fail telling them they should have practiced more before attacking, they will request their clanmates to copy their CW target so they can practice... I'm driving an adult clan, most people have a family and work outside of the game, we can't spend hours copying bases and training on it. We have taken years building real skills in war, being able to adapt our strategy to a base without the need to test it 200x, and even being able to quickly adapt to our troops not doing exactly what was expected. This update is simply removing all the fun out of CW !

If you want people to practice more, give them the ability to war more often by making heroes available in war while upgrading, this would be a real move forward (and I'm not speaking for myself, my heroes have been maxed for a long time) !!!!

[ParanoidAndroid74]

A big question here SC.

How do you stop it being abused in war? My clan has always been 100% fair play and we love war. We love winning honestly and coming out on top because of skill and communication.

Whats to stop unlimited practices on a war base til its 3 starred? Cheap scouts as used to be seen by modding clans?

I cant believe this hasnt been considered by SC. So if the message from SC that its ok for unlimited practicing in war as long as its on SCs terms?

I've been highly positive about what you've done since the TH11 update and thought the game was being reclaimed from the cheats.

But this one single thing (and many of my clanmates are echoing the same comments) could make me turn my back on this game.

War is the challenge. The single shot you get at a base as an individual. Please don't allow that to be removed. Whats the difference between cheating with xmod/ imod and this?

[Saukin94]

That's too much man, simple fix would be no practicing on war day and your war base is your current layout until war day begins where it will automatically switch to your designed war base!

This removes the enemies chance of copying your war base (unless it's the same as your regular base but who does that?) and it still allows them to see your defences levels to still strategise who they will attack!

[Vikingchief]

I'm sure feature will be disabled during full 48 hours of war and in that case will be awesome.

[Hoardy]

If you have a valid concern about it then post it here:

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...y-Challenge%21

It's really irritating to keep up.

Thanks!

[Smarty1]

And how does that stop players in the op clan?

[PhantomPhoenix]

SC is super desperate to keep players! Just look at the troop training ujpdate! Can't complain tho.

[toze]

i think 48 hours and its perfect....
24 means people can still practice once war starts

problem solved

seems the only good idea for now if the friendly challenge advances