Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[SpeakerForTheDead]

I have a better idea than the one they've come up with: why don't they allow us to hit a base we already hit in war for practice once war is over. This way, we can see what we have done wrong, get a little practice in, and no worries about cheaters.


Edit: Another way to keep it FairPlay is to only challenge people in global.

[TommyBallz]

now the enemy can take as an example my war layout and keep training in clan challenges...
then attack zzzz
its like legal modding

Somewhat. yes, i can see great opportunities for abuse here. You still wont be able to see the enemy bomb and trap positions and you will have to guess whats in the castle, but at least you will get better at pathing your troops through...maybe checking trigger castle radius.. will take time to build the base. and i assume you will have to train and lose your troops anyway. so it will be costly. Makes putting up a fake war base all the more important to give enemy less than one day practice time.

Edited bases can only be attacked after 2 days.

even if this is true, go and edit a war base in another friend clan and practice there [abusive, yes, but hard. needs two Town hall villages in a separate clan exactly similar. OK maybe only one, since you can go join the other clan and attack the one base there.....]

TL;DR
This is game changing. You can model enemy war bases, at the cost of your time, and troop elixirs. Troll war bases are all the more important now. Will be fun within clanmates though to attack each other.

[Sidrick]

What do you suggest people do? I think everyone is allowed to have initial thoughts on the idea and present them to others for discussion. That's part of the reason why people come to a forum isn't it?

Seems so. To write off ideas before seeing them in action

FWIW, your post a few pages ago sums up my thoughts perfectly, but I'm sure someone at SC didn't just come up with this overnight and decide to launch it today.

Give it a go..... then have a moan if you don't like it.

[krazyklank313]

War was the last thing worth playing for. Now idk looks like the end of clash

[MontclairTAZ]

Don't like this update at all. Basically legal modding rewarding those with tons of time to spare. I really hope there is a 48 hour delay to attack any new base design.

[ejlfour]

i love that i finally have the oppurtunity to train some of my clanmates and get there skill levels up too where they should be.

[Frostspike]

How is this not fair play if its available to everyone?

Ita just th5 people being angry

[inspira]

It takes more effort to do a Simulation but its ok.

[Arunhayday]

In clan war, one of your player can attack number 1 early and know the placement of giant bombs and traps etc then design the base exactly the same and ask your number 1 to practise by attacking it and after getting the perfection then finally attack enemy number 1 and get 3 star or 2 star with high percentage before war ends. This is what going to happen. This is not good supercell

[ParadoxalAxioma]

Agree with this. Hope they disable the feature on prep day for the duration of the war. Say, once you start a search it disables it for the entire clan until the war is over. If not this will be exploited to the fullest.

I totally agree with this idea.
I'm a hardcore war player myself and this update can kill wars completely.

But on the flipside,
you also have clans doing wars now and then, and mostly small ones.
If they implement this feature, you'll punish every other member of that clan who isn't in war
and those who want to trophy push.

Just my 2 cents