Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[GwennyPants]

People you simply don't allow a challenged base to be attacked if it isn't two days old. Simplest fix in the book!!!! There, all loopholes are closed, an excellent idea SC!

This was my suggestion as well...wait 48 hrs for a newly designed base to be eligible to be attacked

[King4ever]

The entire war community would quit. It's all about 100% custom build strats for perfect raids. What if I build for a queen charge with split heroes, single zap quake and mass drags? Then it turns out that I can't pick up more then 1 ad on my queen charge and my barb ks can't pick up another? Game over.

I think you answered your own question, custom build strat for perfect raids. That has in my opinion nothing to do with skill, but just with how much time you are willing and able to invest in a war attack. Only gonna get worse with Friendly Challenge. Build an army, test it, fine-tune it, test it and keep repeating until you get a 3-star. Good luck with that, not my idea of fun in war. going in blind with a generalised army and trying to push percentage as high as possible would be far better imo.

[Rwawes]

We waited four years for this feature.

[Logeeny]

This sounds great! 3 Suggestions:

1. Please give challenges their own tab, not just a listing in the clan chat.

2. Please make them toggle on/off so I don't have to re-issue a challenge every time someone attacks.

3. Please list challenge attacks in replays.

[Jwp721]

This was my suggestion as well...wait 48 hrs for a newly designed base to be eligible to be attacked

Unfortunately that has been ruled out by all the complainers here who amazingly have the ability to know exactly how it is going to work even before it is rolled out...

[jerdiya]

Supercell pls NO, u were going in the right direction n suddenly you have taken this decision, Wars will not be fun again

[bbdoc]

1) You don't know the trap locations.

Same as xmod... Anyway you don't need to be that smart to guess where most of them can be, and if this is not the first attack on a base, you probably already know a lot.

2) You don't know the CC troops without a proper scout that pulls them.

Same as xmod

3) You can't recreate an enemy base unless someone in your clan has the exact same upgrades done, most people are not in all max TH11 clans... certainly won't be a issue for my mixed clan for a very long time especially since we are engineered with odd upgrade orders.

I have a fully maxed TH11 and all I need is 1 other perso in my clan to have it as well so I can practice. And yes, this is the case, and from our recent opponents, I can tell you this is the case for most of them.

4) Most people used Xmod to cheat because they are lazy. Most won't put the effort in to recreate an enemies base just so their mates can practice against it especially when you factor 1-3 above.

Where did you get that from ? Even using xmod, you had to practice for several hours to Ensure a 3*. People were not using xmod because they were lazy but because they wanted to ensure winning all their wars, and could afford spending hours and hours training on a base to get there

[Burners]

Is it safe to say that the FPC and the modding community both dislike this update?

[Jwp721]

Is it safe to say that the FPC and the modding community both dislike this update?

Nope... I haven't seen it in action so I haven't made up my mind... I know I am the minority here though as others have some amazing ability to know all the details even before it is released... lol

My clan chat is starting to fill up with people saying they want to challenge each other. Ohh such a bad thing to create some fun into the game...

[jerdiya]

IF supercell implements this, i would like to suggest that a clan mate can do a friendly challenge only once in 24hrs time period,