Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[iWearOveralls]

I'm ready to show my clanmates with weak bases how bad they are when I crush them,lol

[BrimstoneManor1]

This is not about "fair". This is about taking something away from people... The work and time they invested in making war bases and learning to be better attackers. This takes the shine off wars now. Bottom line. People can argue and say this is great. Well no it is not and what is right or wrong (good/bad) does not change person to person. This is not good/bad because you personally like/hate it. This is bad because it is removing a skill level requirement from all of us just by its nature and also gives a disadvantage to those of us who do not WANT to use this feature. So, many may say... adapt, grow, be the real chief...etc. Right, I hear you. But realize that just because this is the way it will be does not make it "right". It will be tainted and worth less. At least to me. I can only hope that SC reads any/all of the posts by people who are legitimately concerned here. Not happy about this. And to think say that this will not be abused in war is a lie (or lying to yourself).

Yep your right this is a very bad idea this game is about skill not repetitive attacking till you get three !!!

[BrimstoneManor1]

Tons of ♥♥♥♥ posts here of nabs who think ppl will use it like sandboxing or copying bases or whatever ♥♥♥♥ they sayin, well some nabs will try it but when they see its like tons of ♥♥♥♥ time killing, they will stop...

the easiest counter to copy basing is just make one ♥♥♥♥ base and use it during clan war preparation, when its about to end change it... its just so easy u have to think a bit maybe..

I disagree I think it's a very dumb idea Always have hated the idea and always will hate the idea this game is supposed to be about skill not repetitive attacking to get three

[Crustyslayer]

So now if u are in a war and the enemy is strugling on your base all they have to do is build it and hit it as many times as they need untill they three star it.? Why ban xmod? Supercell this game was just getting good again and u do this ,wars are the only reason this game is on my tablet now you are ruining that for me. Two years of my life I have played this game almost everyday ,well I feel I can see that changing soon

[Crustyslayer]

Fool I can build any base in an hour so il build your base after the start

[Adomus]

Ohh I've read the thing that's the problem, it's all the whining I've been reading for the last 5 months... it's on YouTube it's on the forums it's everywhere and it's constant... it's just people lurching from one complaint into the next as if theyve become completely negative about everything... we need some freaking happy pills for people round here cos your making this place feel like living in a bloody old people's home or some balls where everyone's miserable constantly and waiting to die, where no one visits cos they don't wanna be dragged down by the miserable old codgers lol

Aside from your obvious inflammatory comments about me - I notice you are still broad-stroking over the actual discussion. Make it relevant or just watch.

The last update was well received, as was the one previous.

[dizzlmcwizzl]

I think the solution to the perceived sand boxing problem is very, very easy. Much more so than 48 hour rules or only hitting past war bases.

i think supercell should simply put a time limit on friendly attacks. Just like requesting cc troops can only be performed every ten minutes or so .... The difference for friendly battles is that you are only allowed to be friendly attacked 1 time per day ...

yes people will practice as nauseum if given the chance. However, only the most die hard will put in an hour or two to design a base that may not even be an exact replica so someone else can make a single practice attack. That's a lot of effort for one attempt. If you can get multiple clan mates to put in that time for you .... Good luck.

[Adomus]

I think the solution to the perceived sand boxing problem is very, very easy. Much more so than 48 hour rules or only hitting past war bases.

i think supercell should simply put a time limit on friendly attacks. Just like requesting cc troops can only be performed every ten minutes or so .... The difference for friendly battles is that you are only allowed to be friendly attacked 1 time per day ...

yes people will practice as nauseum if given the chance. However, only the most die hard will put in an hour or two to design a base that may not even be an exact replica so someone else can make a single practice attack. That's a lot of effort for one attempt. If you can get multiple clan mates to put in that time for you .... Good luck.

Best Idea for the day. Props to you.

[BrimstoneManor1]

This is what happens when you don't read posts. Noone is saying it wont be fun for your clanmates, the major discussion point is to prevent it being used to pre-determine war outcomes.

Yes it will affect wars if there is not something put into affect

[Mark122374]

So this is like sandbox mode in Xmod? but you can only attack your clan members?

not sure but Ifor your using xmod, not a good idea to post it in here