Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[KabobKnight]

I haven't heard this from a single person here. Please think of this scenario.

The war is close, in a 40vs40, both clans have 115/120 stars. One clan has a th9 has their top th9 2 starred, while the enemy team has a th9 2 starred as well. Traps are COMPLETELY VISIBLE. 1 hour left in war. One player in their clan who is also a max th9 decides to copy the base and the exact locations of the traps, fills the cc the exact same as the war map. The player who has his attack left sandboxes until he finds the 3 star recipe! The player performs this attack and 3 stars with ease. The other team, who has a life, does not have time to cheat, and they lose. Sure this is an exaggerated scenario. Imagine if its th10 bases. "Oh but they can disable it during war?" Okay. What if this clan makes a new clan with a mini, and then whoever wants to sandbox goes there, sandboxes, and then comes back. SUPERCELL WHAT ARE YOU THINKING?!?! Why not make two game modes for war then?! One game mode that's the same as it is now. And one game mode for xmod players, and have them compete there? That way you can regain the lost revenue? Thanks!

[NewtTheSlayer]

Not if supercell implements a 48 hour practice freeze on all newly created bases. This would stop the feature from being abused in war--real clan or burner clan.

My dear sir, you have just boosted my spirits... Thanks for the insightful reply.

[DaGinga]

Don't listen to that garbage supercell! When people actually try to copy war bases and realize they don't know where traps are, etc and spend tons of time trying to perfect attacks, only to fail anyway, nobody will be complaining. A clan would have to spend the entire day arranging bases, training different armies, guessing at trap locations and cc troops, just to realize it didn't give them much of an advantage on that one attack they worked so hard for. Lol. Most good players are adults with lives and jobs etc. This is great addition that we've wanted forever. The grass is always greener..... Lol

[BolshoiToo]

First off, outside of war this is a really good idea. I have wanted it for years, and was disappointed that SC had ruled it out.

In wars, I think it is one of SCs worst ideas ever, and it is likely to ruin the game for me. A cool down would eliminate the ability to do war sandbox runs. It wouldn't have to be for 48 hrs. 24 hours in theory would be enough. People would just have to put up decoy bases.

[DaGinga]

I haven't heard this from a single person here. Please think of this scenario.

The war is close, in a 40vs40, both clans have 115/120 stars. One clan has a th9 has their top th9 2 starred, while the enemy team has a th9 2 starred as well. Traps are COMPLETELY VISIBLE. 1 hour left in war. One player in their clan who is also a max th9 decides to copy the base and the exact locations of the traps, fills the cc the exact same as the war map. The player who has his attack left sandboxes until he finds the 3 star recipe! The player performs this attack and 3 stars with ease. The other team, who has a life, does not have time to cheat, and they lose. Sure this is an exaggerated scenario. Imagine if its th10 bases. "Oh but they can disable it during war?" Okay. What if this clan makes a new clan with a mini, and then whoever wants to sandbox goes there, sandboxes, and then comes back. SUPERCELL WHAT ARE YOU THINKING?!?! Why not make two game modes for war then?! One game mode that's the same as it is now. And one game mode for xmod players, and have them compete there? That way you can regain the lost revenue? Thanks!

First of all, it would be the guy that also has the max th9 with similar hero's that needs to do the attacking, so he couldn't be the one to copy the base. Second, every good clan knows to start at a time where your top 5 players will have the last 2 hours of war free. Third, both clans have the same advantage!!! This isn't cheating, just like any war ever... The clan who prepares the best and puts in the best effort and talks about attacks, USUALLY WINS! If a clan is going to go through that much to beat you, they would have kicked your butt anyway!!!

[Tennesseebasketball213141]

so what date will this take place

[Kozmo91]

Does anyone know if the one gem boost is a daily thing or just one gem until the update comes out. I can't find it anywhere.

[MavJ]

I was not registered to this forum before today. I took time out of my day and intentionally registered to mention how I think this idea for the game will be the reason I quit playing after 3 years of commitment if its allowed during wars. Please supercell send us some kind of message that this feature will not be activated during wars. Wars are kinda the only thing keeping me in the game currently along with a few enjoyable farming raids which aren't enough on their own. I understand this will be fair in the sense that we all have access to it, but during war is where its not fair to what the game stands for. In my clan Im not the only maxed member. All I have to do is ask him to duplicate one of the other th11 bases on the war map and I can hit it over and over and over. We war 3 times a week, but I know clans out there so determined to win that they will pay people to attack for them. These people will abuse this feature. I guess I have till the release day before I know if I'm deleting the app or not, but in the mean time please give the war community some hope going forward. Thank you.

[MrAnonymous1113]

Sure people will practice war bases but at least everyone has access to it. It levels the playing field and promotes the flagging social aspect, what's the issue?

Issue is everybody want to see everyone else base trashed but not theirs. A strategy available to all is a foreign concept to some
people.

[HalfThrower1]

Man idk but if they dont somehow make it unusable for war practice then its gonna be rediculous for clans like mine. We do 10v10 to 15v15 wars, and if we ever really have an issue its against only their #1, and vice versa. I can easily see our wars being perfect war ties EVERY WAR. Come on man really.