Introducing the Friendly Challenge!

[SAMWF]

Yeah... copy opponent war base... let clanmate challenge until 3 star... is this an new version of sandbox?

[wkcinaz]

Please don't do this update. There is no fun in it. It takes everything the game was meant for and killing it. Make everyone learn how to attack the old way. But if you do this you really need to make it so the clan can't edit their main base to attack until after war is over. Meaning they can edit their base but members won't be able to attack the new base if its during war. But the base will change for normal use. Other wise you'll have the sandbox clans cheering for joy.

[Billius]

Supercell, the chess game you are playing is perfect. Well done.

1. You started banning modders with the Psychic Octopus to send them into disarray but did not permanently ban them, you gave them a second chance. Rook takes Queen!
2. You introduced fast cook times for heavy armies to improve the game and reward fair players (and we raided a lot of dead banned bases too) Bishop calls Check!
3. You said you would introduce some features into the game similar to what modders were using, and you just did. But you did it in a way that is fair for everyone. Queen calls Check!
4. Mod Developers are cornered and Modders have little incentive to cheat. Checkmate!

[Serum153]

Not all of the bases need to be practiced on, just a few so this can be bad. We are in a really close war right now and having a th8 scout my th9 has already made the real attack easier, now imagine if they had a couple tries let alone unlimited. Or maybe he wants to see how is aq is gonna path, so they can just duplicate1/4 or even a corner my base to match and watch where the aq goes.

Easy fix though...u hit save on ur war base...48hr cool down on that base before it can be challenged

[xXXCHRISXXx]

Why are so many people being naive as to assume that copying the opponents base will be a difficult thing?

I am sure the folks at XMod are breathing a heavy sigh of relief that to get back into the game, they just have to create a base copy routine.

I suspect it could be done without an app.

Take a screenshot of the base... Upload it to a server which returns a script that would run on top of bluestacks to build the base.

Short of banning bluestacks, nothing can be done to detect or combat it. And that's just off the top of my head. I am sure that there are more elegant ways.

This is the winning comment right here guys. Read it then read it again. If they don't disable the feature once a war search is started its going to be exploited, no doubt.

[eskado]

Stop ruining the game sc, coc is getting more and more ridiculous!

[Pobilly]

Is this the answer to the bunnies if u can't beat them join them...now we can see an enemy's base and say that looks hard hey clan mate build a base like that and I can practice it so when war comes it'll be easy
....Very Bad Idea Super Cell u may loose the hard core fair play guys for this

[REINtheGamer]

i already told on our clan's chat that i will always challenge everyone

[nerfedname]

i like these ideas... Good fun ahead for sure

yep, I see this feature as having tremendous potential to boost clan fun and activity.

Of course, I also see the potential for war abuse if the proper safeguards aren't implemented. But I'm cautiously optimistic that such safeguards will be implemented, and that the "pros" will outweigh the "cons." This is my opinion of course, but I don't think Supercell is unaware of the war aspect of this feature...

i already told on our clan's chat that i will always challenge everyone

As my clans most advanced base and heaviest hitter (we're a casual friends/family clan), I already offered a $50 iTunes gift card to the player that can 3* my base.

[Jubjubsteve]

Hasn't this just killed war? Now we copy enemy base design and practice until we crack it, no skill required just a 2nd account and time. Very bad idea SC, and you were doing so well dealing with cheats.