Clan war hoppers. Need penalty!

[Ah2003]

Why is every problem given to supercell? Get loyal members.

[JuggernautXVll]

Not sure about penalties for hoppers, seems like a slippery slope. But I would like to see something in their profile about how many clans they've been in....Let's say each reset. So every 30 days they lose half of their clans that have accumulated over that time span. Don't think they should get a full reset. Be hard to tell who the hoppers are at the beginning of the month. What do u guys think?

[123eric]

Any type of record would help to improve the game.

[prosper12]

I disagree. There are lots of reasons a player would want to leave a team. I don't think they should be punished because they find the situation in your clan undesirable. If you're having a problem where new players are leaving in the middle of war, don't put new players into war. Make them wait and prove their worth and their loyalty before you add them to the line up. That leaves only worthy and loyal players in your wars, and if they leave - well, go back to my first statements.

Its difficult but I agree SC should do something to stop leaving in the middle of a war before attacking. It will be difficult to create something feasible but I am sure one of you will come up with a good idea.

[123eric]

Start a war treasury( similar to the village treasury). For each clan war, bonus given for using all your army. MVP! 2attacks, etc.

Players are given their share only if they are present at the end of the war. Should not be difficult to do most of code could be used from existing village treasury.

Could enhance, clan wars.!

[Rue73]

Start a war treasury( similar to the village treasury). For each clan war, bonus given for using all your army. MVP! 2attacks, etc.

Players are given their share only if they are present at the end of the war. Should not be difficult to do most of code could be used from existing village treasury.

Could enhance, clan wars.!

You already get loot when attacking and a win bonus that should be enough incentive during a war.
You will never stop hoppers, some players just love to screw with other people and upset things, just look around the forums it's doesn't take much to find someone who's boasting of destroying a clan by getting CO and kicking players.
Hoppers are a fact of coc life if you stop them doing one thing they will do something else, protection is better than cure, keeping your clan on ba closed or request setting is the best way to deal with the problem, only except players to are expecting, and go recruit players don't just open the doors and expect them to come to you, if you do you may as well put a sign up saying hoppers welcome!!!

[sangeethsanju]

It should be great and will reduce the spy screen shot I ng wa r bases

[123eric]

Sometimes the problem ,is not the problem, it's your attitude toward the problem

[Aspex]

Sometimes the problem ,is not the problem, it's your attitude toward the problem

Exactly. Which is why SC shouldn't listen to you and make it impossible to leave a clan during war.

[rafi401]

The people who leave in the middle of war are already penalized with non-eligibility of joining next clar war for some time. there is no point in having separate penality