Clan Leaders Want More Data!

[luiavag]

I hope some of you agree with me.

I found myself wasting a lot of time surfing through my clan members bases to check out its overall progress in defensive and offensive state and to figure out how active they are and so I could decide whether to put him/her in my next war or not. Probably this is not the case for everyone in well established clans as communication and activity may be very good.

For this reason, my feature request is the following:

In the war participants list when you are about to start a war and decide who is in, it'd be very useful if leaders could see additional data such:

1. The participant TH level (e.g. TH8),
2. The percentage of defences upgraded relative to that TH (e.g. 80% Defence Upgrades Completed),
3. The percentage of troops upgraded relative to that TH (e.g. 60% Offence Upgrades Completed),
4. Lastly, the player's activity factor and this one could be colour coded (e.g. Red=Low activity, Green=Very High activity).

With the implementation of this feature I could "in a fly" decide which bases are the best candidates for my next war.

P.S. I have emailed Suppercell this info and they liked the idea, however they asked me to post it here to share it and see if it has good reception.

[Hamed35]

I love this idea, maybe add who donated troops during war and show what they donated, or something similar.

[prosper12]

4. Lastly, the player's activity factor and this one could be colour coded (e.g. Red=Low activity, Green=Very High activity).



P.S. I have emailed Suppercell this info and they liked the idea, however they asked me to post it here to share it and see if it has good reception.

I like your idea, about clan activity, it is very similar to my post.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ember-activity

[Whatare]

I like the percentage stat. I think it would benefit as a player not just leaders. But would it include walls? Must players I know don't view walls the same as the other upgrades.

[humheartbeat]

I hope some of you agree with me.

I found myself wasting a lot of time surfing through my clan members bases to check out its overall progress in defensive and offensive state and to figure out how active they are and so I could decide whether to put him/her in my next war or not. Probably this is not the case for everyone in well established clans as communication and activity may be very good.

For this reason, my feature request is the following:

In the war participants list when you are about to start a war and decide who is in, it'd be very useful if leaders could see additional data such:

1. The participant TH level (e.g. TH8),
2. The percentage of defences upgraded relative to that TH (e.g. 80% Defence Upgrades Completed),
3. The percentage of troops upgraded relative to that TH (e.g. 60% Offence Upgrades Completed),
4. Lastly, the player's activity factor and this one could be colour coded (e.g. Red=Low activity, Green=Very High activity).

With the implementation of this feature I could "in a fly" decide which bases are the best candidates for my next war.

P.S. I have emailed Suppercell this info and they liked the idea, however they asked me to post it here to share it and see if it has good reception.

I especially like activity factor. It's so hard to determine, I had to make it known multiple times to my members to keep their donation numbers going just so i can determine their activeness. Which of course doesn't always work. Also would really help for leaders to determine whether to kick out inactive accounts from the clan.

[Yachi]

Based on what would you define activity factor? The amount of time player is online, number of won attacks or donation count? Pretty hard to gauge imo. There may be players that travel between clans, so donation count resets. Some farmers don't care about trophies, so as long as they get loot they don't really care if they won the raid or not. The amount of online time is limited by the personal break time. Lol... suggestion is good, just don't know what's best to define activity factor.

We could even add war attack proficiency, like number of war stars scored for each player for the last few wars, but it sounds a little extreme.

[SharkyFinn]

I doubt anything other than simple information like Townhall level will ever be added. Supercell doesn't include statistics that would embarrass a player or enable a leader to oppress his teammates. If you want to micromanage your team's progress, you'll need to do so on your own.