Stupid or Okay (Idea)

[yanks8981]

I think its awful for 2 reasons.

1) 25% is super easy to get. I could barch 25% easily to win a star, regardless how strong the base is. On defense, you would pretty much lose every single time, meaning you would never win trophies.

2) Can you please give me a scenario where its possible to get 4 stars with your system? Wouldnt 100% destruction also be destroying the town hall? Or are you saying that 75% destruction gives you 3 stars and if the TH is part of that, you get 4?

Regardless, it's far better how it is now.

[tallas13]

What if the stars you get from attack in war is total of 5 star?
1 star for 25%
2 star for 50%
3 star for 75%
4 star for 100%
5 star with townhall destroyed

So that 95-99% doesn't hurt a bit, yep it is
but still you must get 50% or 2 stars for the loot.

Stupid or Okay? thoughts?

How does someone get 100% and NOT the townhall?

[Ultr4]

I like the simplicity of three stars. It means for a huge rage of results, such as 1%-99% with only one star. I think that five stars would complicate it, and make the results of attacks a bit more repetitive.

This makes zero sense. 100% means you necessarily destroyed the town hall too . 4 star attacks wouldn't exist. Not much thought must've gone into this post....