Would like to see who donates in war clan castle by selecting each troop. Will help to demonstrate who participates in clan preparation.
Printable View
Would like to see who donates in war clan castle by selecting each troop. Will help to demonstrate who participates in clan preparation.
I agree and members should at least get xp points and a larger percentage back for spending loot on cc castles especially in a war of 40 or more!Quote:
Originally Posted by ChrstnaLne
Agreed. Not fair trying to hunt down the perpetrator. Not everyone is on 24/7 to check whether their castles are filled correctly. We shouldn't even be suspecting clan members! It'll only turn the clan sour from distrust and suspicion...Quote:
Would like to see who donates in war clan castle by selecting each troop. Will help to demonstrate who participates in clan preparation.
Or perhaps having something where donating to warcastles is restricted to certain designated people would be helpful? (maybe have a setting with the warsearch/opt in/out part, there can be a button for [designated donator])
I know some clans do specify who donates; however not all will comply and continue to donate goblins and what-nots. Very stressful for new clans.
I second this. It isn't fair for those donating dragons and valks, witches and what-nots all the time. Strong and expensive troops are the most demanding for wars to ensure victory. Whereas donations for raids, archers and cheaper troops are default for most clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by prosper12
And I've been wondering, why aren't these donations counted towards our donate/receive section?
implement better rules in your clan. we fill the person below us to a certain point (free for all on filling our #1 as long as it's max troops). th 8's where troops won't be max even with 1+ clan perk get filled by 9's and 10's. in the rare case someone doesn't have the max troop requested others in the clan will fill. lastly, get better clanmates. even with this system in place, there are times folks will just cook 5-6 hounds and fill cc's out of the goodness of their hearts, no one feels the need to check in and make sure someone else donated, it's never an issue.
It's not about rules being more firm, it's the rogue players who disregard rules. Particularly in newer clans. Older ones would have already established relationships amongst their team. Whereas newer ones would constantly have to cross their fingers that all the strangers they've recruited are good people.Quote:
Originally Posted by Day2204
that's the pain when growing a clan, especially one where people don't know one another. you can tell who the leeches and weak links are from regular donations. and again, if you're responsible for filling one down (except where max troops aren't available from the person donating) it's easy to see who hasn't filled a request. better systems are needed in clan, not more useless information cluttering the screenQuote:
Originally Posted by Turtlisaur
Quote:
Originally Posted by Day2204
Adding an extra button isn't going to make much clutter - or any at all. And yes, growing a clan is a pain. You will see a pattern in new clans where there will be at least 1 case of a rogue donater.
You can make as many rules as you want. But they will still ignore it regardless.
Yes! Been wanting this for awhile now...
I just posted a simiIar thread before I figured out how to use the search button better, but I had a few more ideas also.
I do like this one as well, it just sounds more difficult to implement as far as programming wise.
Love this. You should be able to hover over a donation and have it tell you who donated it. Ez fix to a lot of problems. But it'll take SC 2 years to figure that out. Lol.