Printable View
I am a leader of a clan that has recently experienced two massive kicks by two rogue elders. Myself and others think elders should not be able to promote people and should have a limited amount of people they kick in a 24hr time frame. We shouldn't have to make everyone elder to ensure that others don't get kicked. Elder should be a position that people want to have and should work to earn. Anyone agree?
Keep a better lock on who you, as a leader, promote to elder and stop handing it out to everyone who donates/asks for it. Sure elders shouldnt be allowed to promote but you need better judgment on who you promote
sorry man, but riff is right.
There should be a button to make an elder top elder. So if u go offline u can make someone top elder so they have power of kicking a regular elder . Then when they go offline they can pass it to someone else who is trusted . And so on :)
Ehh.. this is in the sticky (high elder).Quote:
Originally Posted by curlyfries200
Although better judgement should be made before promoting clan members; CoC is, obviously, a game made for people of all ages. So I think this is a good idea for younger aged clan leaders who don't always have the ability to read other players and their motives.
One of the only reasons I agree with this is because a few months back I was part of a clan where an elder decided to kick everyone before he left as well. It kind of sucks for the players who enjoyed being in the clan too.
Maybe restrict to like 5 kicks a day.
Just make sure you're promoting who you trust, just like raff said. Instead of SC implementing this whole other thing.
We use a voting system to promote elders. We just got played. And one was paid by a past member who we upset. Cant control that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Riffats
cooldown time has been requested a lot. also, dont give elder to people unless you trust them completelyQuote:
Originally Posted by Virgo
Bro its written on sticky and says every 5 mins before kicking again or more than 5 mins.Quote:
Originally Posted by Virgo
You are very right,i'm also a clan leader and i had 2 major kicks by 2 elders. really annoys me.An elder may not promote other people to elder unless it has a special permission from the leader, they should also add new placements like: co-leader, vice-elder...etc
By your philosophy why have elder at all? You are essentially making elders back into regular members if you take away the little influence they have (promoting and kicking lower ranks) and placing ALL responsibility onto the leader.Quote:
Originally Posted by zombie
Then you completely contradict yourself by proposing more placements? :confused: "Elders shouldn't be able to do anything, but there needs to be more ranks of vice-elders that can do more."
Scratching my head on that one.
This has been discussed countless times. I agree there should be a better rank system, I disagree about taking all the elders power away; other wise why have them?
I agree with what u said about that elders should be able to do things, or else why have them. But I think the main issue is them being able to kick some many people at will. Like others have said there should be a limit per day or a "cool down" time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wa11er98s
Quote:
Originally Posted by Riffats
I have to disagree!! I promoted someone after a month of service and over 100 donations - they kicked out my top two players and left!! I think that Elders should not be allowed to kick out any player - only the Leader should have that option!!
Why are you bumping this old thread. It was created before the co leader update so is no longer relevant.Quote:
Originally Posted by DRight812
Agreed....Wonder how much searching it took for the guy to find it....Quote:
Originally Posted by Nmills