Printable View
Hello. I am using this forum to propose an idea to the game. For those who try to create a solid clan and have problems because of other players who just Join a clan and after a second leave, it must have to exist a contract to prevent this situation, for example the player who joins the clan, have to accept a stipulation defined for the clan lider, and if he leaves without respect the contract he loses resources (example). What do you think?
Bad idea. And I'm being nice.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinokoo
Yiur idea penalizes people joining and looking for clans where they fit in. God knows a clan full of kids cursing is not what the adults are looking for. And a clan that has a terrible war log would be an immediate reason to leave for someone serious about war. You can't penalize players for clans that suck or are full of rude people.
There are reasons to leave.
1. Donate hoppers. Some clans are grateful to get them to come by.
2. Joined wrong clan. Oops.
3. Joining for war in an hour but the guy recruiting you lied and there is 22 hours left in prep day.
4. Clan is promised to be active and isn't...
Oh the list goes on.
Don't worry about the hoppers. Its every tenth person that is the keeper. The rest just hop or didn't find a match.
The only hopper that would bother me is a war hopper, but a clan can wait a bit to test loyalty before they let new joiners be in a way.
A good counter to hoppers would be a profile listing all clans a user has been in during the past two weeks. If they are hoppers, don't accept.
... and the reqnleave clan will be close down
lol....Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinokoo
firstly, wrong subforum.
second, this is along the same category of multiple "ruled out" ideas, check the proper subforums first before posting.
third, why should a player be forced to remain in a clan he doesn't like? A leader could potentially troll the contract, the player joins the clan, gets harrassed and mistreated and now gets punished for leaving? lawls there's so many problems with your idea, that I'm starting to consider if your suggestion is legitimate or if I'm being trolled. What if a 6 year old that can barely read joins an adult oriented clan to join with a chat log filled with sexual innuendo and cussing. This child is now punished for leaving?
Fourth, this is a self serving suggestion that will only benefit a tiny tiny minority of the clash community if it even was implemented (which it won't). If you make a suggestion for a change to the game, you might want to start looking at your own clan, and what attraction and perks you can offer new players joining instead of asking SC to fix it for you. Fix your own stuff first, nothing is broken with players coming and going from clans.
-Ace
The problem isnt bad clans but people, who just want to have co-lider privilegies and good troops donated. And do you think that the main problem is too bad clans to fit in, or a lot of kids who just want to be beneficieted?
Ace everyone can have opinions. And after your answer I see that there are no respect for others Ideas in this forum. You are just like this people I am talking of.
Ace and a few of the other people above really made it quite clear why your proposal really wouldn't work. Trust me, I've been quite annoyed in the past with clan hoppers too but the truth of the matter is, the clan you are in may not be a good fit for someone new joining and they may realize this early on after joining and just decide to leave and try to find a more suitable clan. It's just going to happen and you really need to just get to a point where it doesn't bother you any more. If you work hard with your clan to help make it as strong as possible, your clan will become more attractive to other good players who want to come be a part of it, who will stay and be loyal and help contribute. Just focus on bettering your village and your own attacking ability so you can be stronger in wars and help your clan be more attractive to other good players. Eventually you'll be able to cherry pick people you want in your clan and don't need to hope for randoms to just come along and join, only to just leave moments later.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinokoo
This is where the clans I'm in are at now with regard to this issue. Our clan is usually set to closed currently, despite having several available places for new potential clan mates to join. We have a strong core of active players who help keep the clan chat fairly lively and many other growing players who are getting stronger every day, all who donate well and contribute to the clan, participate well in wars, etc. Both the clans I'm in are fairly attractive for other players out there looking for a solid clan to join so we get to cherry pick people based on who we feel will be a good fit to our clan group and it's working out wonderfully.
Clan hoppers are no longer really an issue in the game for me, it's great.
As far as people joining your clan and asking for co-leader privileges, in my clans, we explain to those people that co-leader can be earned after a fairly significant amount of time spent in the clan. It is earned through loyalty, activity (the more active you are consistently), willingness to help out any and everyone in the clan as frequently as you are able to (by donating troops as frequently as possible and by helping give strategy advice for good compositions to use vs certain bases and how to go about attacking those bases, etc.), and just by being a strong clan mate who shows the whole clan that they really are there to help and support the clan.
If you break down what's important to you, for new people joining, to do to earn co-leader, you should quickly weed out those individuals who aren't up to your standards. Those who are up to your standards and see the merit in what you expect of them will more likely be strong, loyal additions to your clan.
I sure hope some of this info can be useful or helpful to you so you can minimize the annoyance of clan hoppers while building your clan up stronger and stronger!
Good luck sir.