Feedback: My Personal Opinion
I'm going to give feedback point-by-point and then general feedback at the end.
1.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Anoushka[Supercell]
Introducing the new Star Bonus! Win five stars in Multiplayer attacks in order to win a daily resource bonus!
Depending on the size and requirements of the bonus, this could be good. But if it's going to require my mid-level town hall 9 to go up to Champion's League for it to really make a difference, then I'll be completely unaffected by this part.
2.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Anoushka[Supercell]
Housed in your Clan Castle, the Treasury is the safest place to store resources. Your daily Star Bonus and War Loot Bonus are automatically stored in the Treasury for safeguarding and only a very small percentage can be stolen.
Okay. That seems fine. Will the capacity of the Clan Castle's Treasury be increased to house the extra loot? Or will we have to empty it just as frequently anyway? Or could we choose how much to take out of the treasury (that would be cool).
3.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Anoushka[Supercell]
Last but not least, we’ll introduce the Loot Cart. After your village has been attacked, a percentage of the stolen resources will be added to a Loot Cart in your Village. Once you collect the resources from the Loot Cart, these will be transferred to your Treasury for safeguarding.
This is confusing. Will the Loot Cart be an actual building? Or will it just be some pretend place and we click a button to transfer loot from the Loot Cart to the Clan Castle? And what's the capacity of the Loot Cart? Will we be able to just allow loot to accumulate indefinitely, or do we only get the loot from the Loot Cart from the most recent raid while losing the Loot Cart loot from previous raids?
General Feedback:
This update seems okay. I'm not expecting it to change the game much though. The big question in my mind is: how much are you going to tinker with the matchmaking system this time? Are you going to keep inactive players' villages invisible? The matchmaking system changes you made with the last update were the biggest catastrophe for my style of play.
To the people who like the update
Explain the purpose of clan castle troops for defensive purposes guarding your home base loot.
Lets say they do their job, they defend, you don't get a shield, lose loot....traps.. Since you don't get a shield PBT is glitchy with some people
no troops. Increased chances of only getting hit once for a shield, and you don't have to donate like crazy so you don't feel like a troop moocher in your clan.
Dont get me started on double poison. Guessing this was more for a war option. It does at least help with the only getting hit once 😆😂
Treasury, loot cart?e explainations, how does it work, Or is just more compliaction
It is hard to trust now that this will help the game without more information, more complication, more chances with little communication, what has changed?
Fixing loot - you're doing it wrong.
We don't want free loot. What is really needed and I saw it coming as soon as the sneak peeks dropped: SIGNIFICANT decrease in troop training time and cost.
A clever SEMC employee once said "We don't create a game to make money, we make money to create a game"
maintenance time subtracted to time session :((
Hi,
Hope this is the right thread for this.
The session time runs during maintenances.. This is not fair for high level trophies.. Every minute counts and this morning those, like me, who were during their session when it cut have lost one hour which is huge in titan 1 league.
Of course maintenances are needed, but the session and personnal guard could be suspended during maintenances as it is for the boosts.
Tranining Times NEED CHANGED!!!!!!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kmskrs
I still enjoy the game, I realy like the update, I have never been a fan of sniping and sniping is correctly not the way the game was intended to be played. How many CoC-copies have the Sniping-options?
But since sniping is out, building a real army, takes to long time. You could attack with bow, but that is allmost impossible now, so you need to build a real army, and that takes to long...... 1,5 hours between attack is the real problem i belive. People no longer stays online, because it takes to long to build, and then chat is out.
Completely agree here!!!! I only sniped TH because it was a quick way to go out and raid again. I didn't have to use all my troops AND THEN WAIT FOREVER TO RAID AGAIN!
Please decrease the training time, lower the price per troop slightly and this game would be back to booming! Clans would be more active, chat would revive and popularity of the game would increase.
Respect our Intelligence!!!!
Its so pathetic to see that just to get rid of th-sniping supercell is coming with so many "houdini acts".
that wasn t the way to play the game, to get a percentage of ur stolen loot back, is that the way to play the game?
Since december (disaster) update the game is totally broken, th sniping was in ur eyes maybe wrong, but it made the (social + economic) dynamics in the game perfect!
And removing dead bases was a bug? Come on supercell thats just an insult, you are undermining our intelligence.
Dead bases does not fit either in ur eyes to play the game, you want us to make big armies and attack, dead bases dont need big armies.
Is it really sooooo difficult to say, ok, we made a couple of mistakes? Please respect our intelligence and dont lie, removing dead bases was not a bug.
You're Losing Your Market Share SuperCell!
I remember reading a quote from SuperCell that they "wanted to create a game people would play for years." Unfortunately this is no longer that game as it would take a LIFETIME to max out a base without spending gems and it's no longer fun.
It's much like a roller-coaster ride at an amusement park. You wait in line for hours only to enjoy a 2 minute ride. If you want to ride again, it will take a couple more hours. The only "fun" we have is the 3.5 minute attack we get to do every couple of hours due to training times and resource costs.
I'm trying to stick it out to see if there are improvements, but I'm trying new games. Hopefully SuperCell is REALLY PAYING ATTENTION to this forum and others and get these issues fixed before the NEXT BIG THING comes along and takes the spotlight.
This game is your bread and butter SC......get it together to keep it together!
Everyone needs to chill out
I find it insane that everyone is freaking out on SC like this. Did they take away TH sniping? Yeah. And ya know, if you actually enjoyed dropping four archers and moving on to the next one then I guess I got nothing to say, but that seems super boring and lame to me anyway. The only difference to "farming" now is just that you need to make a slightly more powerful army. I have not only been doing as well as I was pre-update (I was a barch-er), I'm actually doing BETTER now (now with balloonion). SC is trying to regain the integrity of the game. It was dumb that people could ♥♥♥♥♥ the system with TH's on the outside. And to counteract this, SC helped a ton. Loot bonuses going WAY up which is awesome as long as you aren't being a whimp and hanging out in crazy low trophy ranges, then that's your problem. They significantly decreased traps/x-bow reloading which is super helpful. And not to mention, YOU CAN ATTACK 3-4 TIMES WHILE YOU STILL HAVE A SHIELD!!!! Does that mean if I get attacked more I will lose more loot? No. Because if you're even remotely decent at the game, you can attack 3-4 times and get easily more loot than what you lost. With no penalty. So for people who were lazy, yeah it sucks that you can't ♥♥♥♥♥ the system now. Get over it.
And now SC is essentially giving us free loot. Who cares what it's called? IT'S FREE LOOT. They are trying to please all of the obnoxious people who keep complaining. They're doing a dang good job of listening to people's input. SO STOP COMPLAINING. Everyone is sick and tired of hearing it. The post update game is substantially improved, and they're continuing to try to please everyone. If you're gonna come on these forums and complain even more, first why don't you try to actually play the game. You might find that if you aren't an idiot about it it's actually pretty dang good.
New Clash is the awful New Coke
Long ago a corporate giant had perhaps the largest share of their market. They had millions of people who loved their product just the way it was. They also put out commercials that people enjoyed and all their customers shared their products loyally with friends and family. One day, for reasons that no one understands to this day, Coke decided that they were going to change the formula of their product. Overnight New Coke became the only Coke that was out there. It was terrible. From their massive market of consumers only a few die hard Coke drinkers continued to choke down the "new and improved" Coke. BUT, and it is a very, very big BUT, the vast majority of the consumers HATED this change. They complained among themselves and then to the company. Coke tried desperately to pay no attention to them, hoping that they would learn to like the New Coke but soon their massive market share began to seriously dwindle. Without explanation or really any apology Coke began producing "Classic Coke". And they managed to win back their market. You no longer see New Coke. It was a sad and potentially self destructive change. Equally important for the history lesson is that Coke still exists today and continues to have a worldwide vast market. They say that those who don't learn history are doomed to repeat it. I hope maybe you are capable of learning and bring back the option of "Classic Clash".
When will the next dark barrack update be?
When will the next dark barrack monster come out
I found a dead base at lunch today!
450k elixir and gold and 700 DE...
Hurray!
Reduce troops/Heros/spell training time
SC
I hope you reduce the training time of troops/spells/Heros to match the PBT. As it is it takes 2+ hours of training (waiting) to train an army to do full attacks.
That is 3 min of play times vs 120 min of wait time=very boring gameplay
So after 6 min of playing time before getting the big PBT boot that says we've been playing too long.
So 6 min of actual game play is too much time spent playing and you need a break. Lol.
Add a fix for this in your loot cart patch
Thumb up for attending to the loot issues
Thanks SC- although the communication is a bit late it's better than never and hopefully this will rejuvenate our clan a bit. Looking forward to testing it out once rolled out.
Make things more simple?? And solve other issues. Two birds one stone
So after hearing about the loot crate it seemed like a ok way to go about it. However would it not make more sense to lower the amount of loot u can steal from players by say 30% and up the league bonus by 30%. This way people are more motivated to go in higher leagues and that's a lot less complex then loot crates. I feel like that already made things complex with shields. Been playing for 3 years and it took me awhile to get the sheild change lol. But I digress. What do u guys think?
Thank you for reading
