[Gem idea] Good Clan = More Gems

Printable View

TLDR; NEW IDEA - NOT MASSIVE EXTRA GEMS & PREVENTS BOTS, allows players who improve clan to get more gems and prevents stagnant players

Gem Collector
Gem box supplement
People who improved this idea:

Deadtoast15 - only some of the gems goes to enemy from war, decrease gem box gems
CometSmudge - add gems for defending in farming/trophy pushing

What it is:
Allows for players who improve their clan to gain gems, this can replace the "top clan gem distribution".

No building changes - no new building
Clan will have a section or a screen designated for the Gem collector
Over time, the clan generates gems based on players and their activeness
Gems are only distributed to war players - kind of like old times when kings would give people lands/etc for heroic war activity

How it Works:

The Gem Collector is able to collect certain amount of gems for [a certain amount of stars that are gained from trophy pushing/farming] and for [defending in farming/trophy pushing] (e.g: see tables at end of post (NOTE: NON WAR stars, war does not affect collection) - this allows clans to specialize how active they are)
The Gem Collector's level reflects the sum of each clan player and their trophy level (for example 10 Diamond players will make more gems in a day then 10 bronze players)
Gems are distributed by percent, to only war players at the end of each war (this keeps stagnant players/bots out of clans)
War stars gained per TH level is what percent of the stored gems go to the players (e.g: 2 stars on a TH10 gives more gems than 3 stars on a TH9)

For example a 10 vs 10 war, if all players attack across and get 3 stars, each player receives about 10% of the collected gems
A clan which wars once a week will have 3.5x the gems available at the end of the war, compared to if they warred continuously (this allows casual clan wars; warring LESS FREQUENTLY does not reduce gems)

Why SUPERCELL Should Implement This:

Allows clans to specialize (hardcore active, just friends, etc.)
Promotes active players (especially in war)
Promotes trophy pushing
Promotes good farming
Promotes players to benefit from collaborating strategy tactics

Possible Tweaks:

Replace top clan gems: Distribute to all clans, of course better clans will reap higher rewards of gems because of the higher level gem collector
Winning a war will allow gem collection, losing actually gives the other clan 50% of the collectors gems (HIGHLY prevents bots and makes war more competitive! Also prevents clans purposely matching against each other to increase gem collection)
Decrease gem boxes to have 15 gems to compensate for clan gems

Quote:

Example Data:
Comparison:

1 gem box every 10 days = 913.125 gems/year for one person
Top 3 clans split yearly 9,000 to 30,000 gems/year for one person

The following tables are TEST data to give an example of gem collection:

Trophies Collector Level Gems/Hour Gems/Year
(ENTIRE CLAN) Est. People Gems/Year
(1 Person)

0-3999 1 10 87,660 10 unranked 8,766

4000-7999 2 12 105,192 10 Bronze 10,519.2

8000-13999 3 15 131,490 10 Silver 13,149

14000-19999 4 19 166,554 10 Gold 16,655.4

20000-25999 5 24 210,384 10 Crystal 21,038.4

26000-31999 6 30 262,980 10 Master 26,298

32000-40999 7 37 324,342 10 Champion 32,434.2

41000-19999 8 45 394,470 10 Titan 39,447

50000+ 9 55 482,130 10 Legend 48,213

Activity gives the following gems:

Each two [farming/trophy attack stars] gives the collector 1 gem
Each [farming/trophy defense] gives the collector 1 gem

ATTACK TABLE:

Style People Days Attacks/day Stars/attack Total Stars Total Gems
(CLAN in 5 days)

Casual 10 5 2 1.5 150 75

Casual 25 5 2 1.5 375 187.5

Casual 50 5 2 1.5 750 375

Competitive 10 5 6 2 600 300

Competitive 25 5 6 2 1500 750

Competitive 50 5 6 2 3000 1500

DEFENSE TABLE:

Style People Days Defenses/day Total Gems
(CLAN in 5 days)

Casual 10 5 0.5 50

Casual 25 5 0.5 125

Casual 50 5 0.5 250

Competitive 10 5 2 200

Competitive 25 5 2 500

Competitive 50 5 2 1000

SUMMARY TABLE:
Style People Attacks/day Defenses/day Total Gems
(person in 1 year)

Casual 10 2 0.5 913.125

Casual 25 2 0.5 913.125

Casual 50 2 0.5 913.125

Competitive 10 6 2 3652.5

Competitive 25 6 2 3652.5

Competitive 50 6 2 3652.5

I will continue to monitor and update this post. Please give feedback.

THANKS FOR READING :)

January 9th, 2016
M4573RCH13F

r e s e r v e d THANKS :)
January 9th, 2016
Deadtoast15

1 gem per 30 stars won is not a lot. A lot of clans war 10v10 and 15v15 frequently. That really isn't much. Also how will the trophy pushing gems be distributed? Similar to the clan tournament leagues? Also how does this prevent b.o.t.s.?

Edit: I also do not believe it is fair for a clan to lose all their collecter gems by losing a war. They should just gain less than the winning clan.
January 9th, 2016
M4573RCH13F
Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadtoast15

1 gem per 30 stars won is not a lot. A lot of clans war 10v10 and 15v15 frequently. That really isn't much. Also how will the trophy pushing gems be distributed? Similar to the clan tournament leagues? Also how does this prevent b.o.t.s.?

Edit: I also do not believe it is fair for a clan to lose all their collecter gems by losing a war. They should just gain less than the winning clan.

The 1/30 was for trophy pushing farming and had nothing to do with war.

Also most of the recent changes SUPERCELL has been making and a major trend in their development is to prevent bots. In theory, they can collect Gem Boxes so I will add your idea, thanks.

How does this prevent bots:
1. Winning war increases gem collection (compared to bots brainlessly collecting gem boxes)
2. Trophy pushing and farming increases gems (bots cannot do these)
3. Higher trophy increases gem production (bots cannot maintain high trophy)
Note how Town Hall sniping is gone, PREVENTING BOTS.
January 9th, 2016
Deadtoast15

Quote:

Originally Posted by M4573RCH13F

The 1/30 was for trophy pushing farming and had nothing to do with war.

Also most of the recent changes SUPERCELL has been making and a major trend in their development is to prevent bots. In theory, they can collect Gem Boxes so I will add your idea, thanks.

Ah read the 1/30 part incorrectly. Could you add a section indicating the amount of gems possible to gain in different sizes of war? Just to see if it not too much. I understand that you it percentage margins but it still doesn't help specify how Amy gems total will be at the end of wars. (Gems possible).
January 9th, 2016
M4573RCH13F

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadtoast15

Ah read the 1/30 part incorrectly. Could you add a section indicating the amount of gems possible to gain in different sizes of war? Just to see if it not too much. I understand that you it percentage margins but it still doesn't help specify how Amy gems total will be at the end of wars. (Gems possible).

Yeah I can add. Could you give me a good estimate for REPLACING gem boxes, I believe [one box]/[10 days] per player is accurate?
January 9th, 2016
Deadtoast15

Quote:

Originally Posted by M4573RCH13F

Yeah I can add. Could you give me a good estimate for REPLACING gem boxes, I believe [one box]/[10 days] per player is accurate?

In my opinion I think gem boxes would still be fine. They do not come that often for most. If anything I guess a slight reduction in the amount you get from them? 20?
January 9th, 2016
CometSmudge

I like this idea, but it shouldn't replace gem boxes. Also, maybe some kind of gems added if you win on defense too, and not just attacking.
January 9th, 2016
M4573RCH13F

Quote:

Originally Posted by CometSmudge

I like this idea, but it shouldn't replace gem boxes. Also, maybe some kind of gems added if you win on defense too, and not just attacking.

Thanks, updated as per suggestion.

Trophies	Collector Level	Gems/Hour	Gems/Year *(ENTIRE CLAN)*	Est. People	Gems/Year *(1 Person)*
0-3999	1	10	87,660	10 unranked	8,766
4000-7999	2	12	105,192	10 Bronze	10,519.2
8000-13999	3	15	131,490	10 Silver	13,149
14000-19999	4	19	166,554	10 Gold	16,655.4
20000-25999	5	24	210,384	10 Crystal	21,038.4
26000-31999	6	30	262,980	10 Master	26,298
32000-40999	7	37	324,342	10 Champion	32,434.2
41000-19999	8	45	394,470	10 Titan	39,447
50000+	9	55	482,130	10 Legend	48,213

Style	People	Days	Attacks/day	Stars/attack	Total Stars	Total Gems (CLAN in 5 days)
Casual	10	5	2	1.5	150	75
Casual	25	5	2	1.5	375	187.5
Casual	50	5	2	1.5	750	375
Competitive	10	5	6	2	600	300
Competitive	25	5	6	2	1500	750
Competitive	50	5	6	2	3000	1500