Printable View
We should add a feature to the game to where if a clan leader is offline for 1 week, all coleaders can go to clan settings and select a tab which reads "Impeach Leader".
Leader of the clan will go to one of the coleaders as it would if the leader had just left the clan.
What if he's taking a two week vacation without internet? Now what?
Give back leader when he's back then
Coleader and leader are pretty much the same thing.
A leader should be the most active member of a clan. If he/she is going to be gone for two weeks, they should give the title of leader to a trusted coleaders until they return.Quote:
Originally Posted by Radiating
That is a discussion for you to have with your leader. The leader gets to make these rules.Quote:
Originally Posted by EasyE
Technically, your rule is not required, because any co-leader can run the clan indefinitely.
Why ?Quote:
Originally Posted by EasyE
If the co can't run the clan as co, they can't run the clan as Leader.
If you are in a clan that is instant co to everyone and Leader is the only other rank, leave now. Fast.
What my point is, there is no member in the clan to supervise coleaders if the leader is absent. A clan can not function off of coleaders alone. This is why I believe this function would help improve the quality of the game. Some of us have been in the same clan for years now and have no desire to leave.Quote:
Originally Posted by OzAudi
Nonsense. If they are trusted co and have been there for a year then they should have some ideas on direction and co-operation.Quote:
Originally Posted by EasyE
If you need a wrangler for the co that badly, is it really that nice a place ?
This topic is often dicussed in IFR, but rarely with such a drastic and unrealistic time before removal.
Read 6 to 12 of those threads, just from the last 4 months will do, then come back with sounder reasoning. Your argument has no merit atm.
This feature can be abused in so many ways. The leader created their clan. It is their clan. He/she should be allowed to have and make the decision to stay leader or not. It is extremely unfair for them to be "kicked out" of their clan they are leading. Like one of the other forumers said what if the leader goes on a no wifi break for a few weeks and notifys the cos? The Co leaders can easily turn corrupt and take over the clan. The leader will come back and see he's been kicked out of his own clan. This feature, because of this main issue, isQuote:
Originally Posted by EasyE
a bad idea.
Yes, 1 week is absurdly short. General agreement seems to be that 3-6 months of complete inactivity is more like it. I think SuperCell has been said to remove a Leader on request if the Leader has been inactive (never logging on) for 3 months).Quote:
Originally Posted by OzAudi
There is possibly an argument for auto-promotion to co-leader if there are zero co-leaders and the leader is inactive. However, I have never heard of a clan of worth with zero co-leaders.
What is "IFR"?
IFR...Idea & Feature Request ...this sub-forum.Quote:
Originally Posted by George1971
So I just have to bring a couple troll friends into a group advertising free co, join, impeach leader, and then I get a free group? That's not fair.
If a Leader has made a clan, then they should get to run it by any means possible.
If you're a Co-Leader in a clan with an inactive Leader, you can still run the clan - promote people to Elder, start wars, invite others and edit clan description. Clans don't have to fall apart just because the Leader is inactive.
No. If you're not happy with your leadership join a different clan or start your own.
Seems rather harsh, instead I would suggest leave the clan and start an alternate one. Clan names do not even need to be unique so you could use the same clan name if desired.
That's not fair to the leader. Clans on this game aren't a democracy. Maybe if it was 3 months it would be fine.