Disable clan castle defence

Starting with apologies, I am aware of the fact this topic is ruled out. But these are ruled out before Supercell launched the 'Big Update': a real game play change. You'd better keep your townhall safe.

However I realy like the update, there is one major point anoying me. Because my townhall is inside obligated, I get attacked more often. No problemen there, but my clan castle troops are. As they die during defence of my village, I can not use them for the main purpose I asked my clan castle troops for: participating in clan war.

Therefore I plead for an optioneel to switch off clan castle for multiplayer defence.

This is ruled out, please read the stickies before posting! Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

This is ruled out, please read the stickies before posting! Thanks.

---

Thus again relevant and open for discussion dued tot the update

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NrgTimmY

Thus again relevant and open for discussion dued tot the update

---

I face the same conundrum too and agree with the OP. I don't mind having to fight over defending my loot without a free shield - that's fair game to me. But I really am having trouble as well keeping the troops donated by my clan mates and this affects not only me, but them too - and I have a semi-inactive clan that getting cc troops is something beyond my control. Especially when I may need to wait hours before I get troops from my clan mates.

So while I understand as well that idea of clan castle defenses being toggled off has been ruled out, but I agree with the OP that SC could perhaps look into the issue again after the TH11 update. It is getting rather difficult to estimate when I would get a shield or not as opposed to what life used to be like.

I'm having the same trouble. As a TH10, I'm rarely attacked so it is difficult to predict and our clan requires advance notice.

request when you need them. problem solved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

This is ruled out, please read the stickies before posting! Thanks.

---

Simply replying an idea is "ruled out", should be ruled out.

This idea needs to be looked at again. Especially now that bases are open to being raided more often than before. I support this idea 100%.

I agree with this. They do this for the heroes, and war w/o TH snip and PBT, is more tedious. I've made numerous Golems just to re-make them, sorry some of these armies take hours to make and with PBT its a hassle

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jc1589b

request when you need them. problem solved.

---

We have a small but brave friends and family clan, not everyone van donate lavahounds p.e.
Youre suggestion won't solve the problem

Agreed. This would make war much easier

When I had my TH on the outside, I was able to go for a long time without having my troops drawn out of my CC that I had intended for war. It happened, but not nearly as frequently.

I picture this being used like a king/queen. Where you can have a guard/sleep or active/inactive setting.

Alternatively, we could also get a new building that houses troops intended to defend your base and keep the clan castle for troops you plan to attack with.

Either one I feel could work, and one of them is necessary.

Agreed. A simple switch off of defence would save the troops. Why not? And I also agree with the revisiting post. You can't rule out an old idea comeing back when it's a new game your makeing the idea for.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LokiX6

Agreed. A simple switch off of defence would save the troops. Why not? And I also agree with the revisiting post. You can't rule out an old idea comeing back when it's a new game your makeing the idea for.

---

A fair and simpele solution in deed. And thanks for the suport

Ruled out, please read stickies first. Also 2 simple fixes would be to:

Put all your storages outside so the attacker doesn't lure your troops. Duh.
And request when you need them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PureEnergy66

Ruled out, please read stickies first.

---

I did, did you read my post anyway?

DE storage could do the trick. But not running hot on the idea of a 3000k loss of DE every time I go offline without shield

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PureEnergy66

Ruled out, please read stickies first. Also 2 simple fixes would be to:

Put all your storages outside so the attacker doesn't lure your troops. Duh.
And request when you need them.

---

Wow. Just give away all your loot so the clan war becomes even more resource costly. Must be nice to afford all those gems.

THE GAME HAS CHANGED. THUS THIS SUGGESTION SHOULD BE REVISITED!!!

Agree, while it was ruled out in the past. The game is very different now with unreliable shielding. This is very important for war.