Defensive Win Bonus

We all know that elixir is becoming more and more scarce with this past update and needing to use stronger armies to attack other villages. And the idea of defensive win bonus has been thrown out there but would need to be set so people don't drop one troop and quit to give a large defensive bonus.

While in a discussion with a clan mate over this topic, I had an idea that may work but I haven't really come up with big details.

Your defensive win bonus would be whatever the cost of enemy troops you killed during the attack. That way a one troop drop gives nothing (just like it would for VG), but a full scale GoWiPe for example would give a pretty good bonus if you were able to defend against it. They could even give bonus if you lost but reduce the percentage based on how much percentage/stars you gave up.

Like I said this was just a quick idea I just came up with and haven't come up with a lot of details, but curious what people thought and how could it be made better?

I personally think a one-troop drop should give some sort of bonus as well, maybe depending on the league. Because in sick of going to sleep and waking up to +400 or more in the course of a few hours. I shouldn't have to be in a higher league if I don't want to, because farming armys are pretty much nonexistent for me now to obtain any loot. This update has really iritated me and I think I'd be lucky to be playing in another month. I'm a th10(recently 11 now, actually), and I have made it to about 2.3 Million elixir in my storages total since Thursday. Collectors are essentially useless unless you collect every hour or so because people just drop troops and eventually when (when Im asleep) enough loot is in the collectors it's raided for (and often still no shield given because they're only hitting collectors...)

I totally agree! It's not so easy any more to save elixir and de! How about an additional idea: If you were attacked, and you got no shield (so you defended well, and this has to be rewarded, but you are still without shield and that's not good) you'll get back ALL the ressources the enemy had stolen from you as long as he used 1/3 of his army capacity. What's your opinion about this? Maybe include it to your thread.;)

Three factors should be important.

-Player League (should add as a multiplicator)
-Cost or Housing Space of troops dropped
-Percentage gained my attacker (low percentage ==> less reward; high destruction ==> higher reward)

I had just thought of the same thing, and came here to post it. Your mind was quicker than mine. This is a good start to help the economy.

One day...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WernerDerChamp

Three factors should be important.

-Player League (should add as a multiplicator)
-Cost or Housing Space of troops dropped
-Percentage gained my attacker (low percentage ==> less reward; high destruction ==> higher reward)

---

I agree league should play a factor, as that would help even more with putting players in an appropriate league for their attacking and defending levels. However I think it would be backwards to award a higher bonus for giving up a higher percentage of your base. The point is to reward someone for defending an attack.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pixlon

I totally agree! It's not so easy any more to save elixir and de! How about an additional idea: If you were attacked, and you got no shield (so you defended well, and this has to be rewarded, but you are still without shield and that's not good) you'll get back ALL the ressources the enemy had stolen from you as long as he used 1/3 of his army capacity. What's your opinion about this? Maybe include it to your thread.;)

---

I'm not sure giving back all loot taken would be a good idea as this would allow players to again "scam" the system by only putting storages out for people to hit without giving up enough % to give a shield. But in your scenario they would get a hefty defensive bonus that may outweigh what was lost by defending well.

nice idea,i get a lot of def wins it would benefit me

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Drewsche

We all know that elixir is becoming more and more scarce with this past update and needing to use stronger armies to attack other villages. And the idea of defensive win bonus has been thrown out there but would need to be set so people don't drop one troop and quit to give a large defensive bonus.

While in a discussion with a clan mate over this topic, I had an idea that may work but I haven't really come up with big details.

Your defensive win bonus would be whatever the cost of enemy troops you killed during the attack. That way a one troop drop gives nothing (just like it would for VG), but a full scale GoWiPe for example would give a pretty good bonus if you were able to defend against it. They could even give bonus if you lost but reduce the percentage based on how much percentage/stars you gave up.

Like I said this was just a quick idea I just came up with and haven't come up with a lot of details, but curious what people thought and how could it be made better?

---

Awesome idea! Good job on this topic hope it gets added soon!!!

-CilicBre