Would this new feature be good?

Hi people. I would like to put forward a new idea: a Troop Reception Limit.

As you can see the name itself is pretty self explanatory. This is how it works: you cannot receive any troops if you have a donation count less than half of your reception count. So if you receive 10 troops, you need to donate at least 5, otherwise you can't be given any troops. This idea is intended to punish selfish players who just ask troops every time yet they don't bother even donating archers.

What do you guys think?

Sorry, I don't really like this idea.

Many clans have different required donation ratios and many have no formal ratios at all, it's left to the leaders discretion to have a word if they think someone is leeching.. There are also different scenarios as to when you might need more troops than others at a specific time (for instance if you are pushing and the rest of the clan isn't)

too many variants to have a formal ratio coded in..

This restricts a team spirit where people can get help when they need it, so I don't think this should be implemented, sorry.