[TH9] Which war base should I use? (Anti-3 Star)

I found this anti-3 star design a while back:
http://i.imgur.com/cL121VG.jpg
It seems to be pretty good, and I've used it for a while. Then, I suddenly got wrecked two wars in a row, so I went base hunting. First thing I saw was this:
http://i.imgur.com/YtVy27X.jpg
Which base should I use? Or is there another base I should use?

Definitely the second base. The first base isn't even a good Anti-GoWiPe base with how spread out it is. Also, with the queen in the center and all 4 AD's around it, the base is very prone to GoLoWiPe, GoVaLo, or GoLoWi (for people who associate PEKKAs with 2 star attacks, I personally disagree because PEKKAs are outstanding for the job they are often tasked with: destroying the core of a base).

Base 2 is more "traditional anti-3" in the sense that everything is quite textbook. It's a solid base, but it doesn't have many tricky features. It will definitely defend against many 3 star attacks from mediocre to good attackers. No base is safe from great attackers though so don't worry too much about those.

Edit: I'd also recommend the "Project Isotope" base number 1 (currently the only base) that can be found here: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-TH9-War-Bases I'm personally using a modified version of that base that's more suited to Anti-GoWiPe because I get attacked by GoWiPe a solid amount. Not too many people who are new to 3 star attacking want to attack an Anti-3 base when there are Anti-2 bases that can be tried.

I'd use the second one, but keep in mind it is a very common base.

Base 2. Definitely needs more skills to beat than just throw 4 EQ spells and spam troops

Base #1 can be wiped with a standard 2 star comp with some back-end loons.

Base #2 is the one I actually created. There is an inherent susceptibilty to the MAX attack and the DGB pathing on the left is flawed, so I suggest you change up the bomb locations. The base, named Triton, is also very popular now and is well-known enough to have base breakdowns and players can quickly search online and will find it (a simple google of 'anti-3 star war base' will pop it up in the first few).