The only solution for solving moders in wars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irmtfan

As you know there are a lot of topics everyday in forums about modders and chea***ters in war.
People just want supercell to do something for it but they dont propose a solution.
Now Im coming with a solution and I think this is the only solution which remove all modding in wars for good.
the base is: supercell should remove pre-scouting in war.
Scout = simulations = modding and che***ting.
So clash community should know that we should give something to gain something else.
so my war proposal is:
- each player should setup 3 war base in prep day. All 3 war base cc will be filled by same troops in prep day to avoid conflict.
- in war day nobody can scout the opposite clan bases. they should create army and go attack one of the 3 bases of an opponent.
- when attacker hit attack button he/she has 3 minutes to scout the base and prepare for the attack.
- nobody can attack the base already attacked before. that means your clan only can attack a player 3 times.
- the best stars/destruction for each base will be count. for example if all 3 bases of one player attacked for 2 stars the one with more destruction will be count in war.
- The winning and losing rules is like as it is.


As you can see 3 minutes scout is the only difference from normal raids. IMO it is even more exciting. assume you are in pushing. everybody know that in high cups you should attack any base which offer good cups regardless of the base design. so it is more challenging.

Edit: of course you can see the opposite clan normal bases and find their troops, heroes and defenses level before attacks.

---

howerver totally have to stop stupid ♥♥♥♥♥ers

but its useless, attack enemy without even know what towers he got ?

no one will join war again anymore

I don't think the op has a very good idea but I credit him for having one. Most people just troll. All of these arguments hold water at least somewhat but the main problem is that it just seems like nothing is being done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cezarica

From what I've seen/heard they can simulate an attack on any base without the need of someone attacking the base, but won't know where the bombs, traps, teslas and so on are UNLESS someone has attacked before. And here comes into play that lone barbarian attack, cos after him they can watch the replay and see all the stuff they can't while simulating. :facepalm:

---

Yes. knowing the traps and cc troops is good but without them still che**ter can simulate attack.
In my opinion knowing cc troops is just 1% now. Thanks to new poison spell the diversity is gone and you can be sure most bases has dragons.
So che**ter will add one drag and 2 loons and start practicing. finding tesla and bombs is not hard too. he can change the places of them and practice.

This suggestion changes the clan wars and the game totally for clans like mine. We war with a range of th and have specialist attackers who rely on scouting bases. This is to decide who should attack who and what cc donations are required at what time of day (we are international and not everyone has the same troops or are active at the same time).

Most people would just stick to multiplayer and pass on war. It’s more lucrative and your suggestion removes much of the challenge, fun and chat during prep and battle days.

In about 90 wars, I can think of only one where the result *might* suggest this is a burning issue. Maybe we have lucky.

As someone who is in a max TH10 clan, I would not be very fond of attacking a base and not knowing what I am attacking.
While this might fix one problem, it would completely shatter the very meaning of wars.

Supercell take this matter very seriously, and often have, and will continue to put fixes/obstacles in the paths of those who choose to follow the ways of the dark side.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheMountain19

Practicing for everyone is a decent idea but it would make war to easy below th ten. It's almost needed at te though and might make things interesting.

---

It would but th9 or below are already easy enough. Frankly It would make wars so much more fun for all good players while still maintaining clans that don't wish to spend hours to crack bases so you'll still see easy wars from time to time. Make it th10 only.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irmtfan

I repeat. If chet**er can see that one base he can create it in his simulator app and practice it countless times.

---

Yes, I know. And some players practice attacks in their heads for hours before attacking (which is fair play). There are different levels of war.

My preferred solution is still: total ban. SC should take all accusations of ♥♥♥♥♥ing seriously and simply delete the players that are found to ♥♥♥♥♥.

A secondary solution would be to pit clans from "certain parts of the world" against each other .. let them duke it out on a level playing field ..

/Affront

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irmtfan

I repeat. If chet**er can see that one base he can create it in his simulator app and practice it countless times.

---

What i have understood, SC fixed pretty much this issue. Yes, you can scout & copy base, but you can't see traps, teslas & cc troops. But then these losers found another workaround. When attack is done, whole base with these hidden things is loaded to client. Thats why bunny users now seem to do 1 barb attack to top villages with their lower villages, then few hours later their top villages attack and voilá, 3 star.

This would simply destroy diversity and innovation. Who would try a risky new set up or higher risk strat without even seeing the base? It would be all Dragons up to a point then All GOWIPEs.

By far the worst solution I have seen. This will mean that we cannot make an army suitable for the layout :thumbsdown: