The only solution for solving moders in wars

As you know there are a lot of topics everyday in forums about modders and chea***ters in war.
People just want supercell to do something for it but they dont propose a solution.
Now Im coming with a solution and I think this is the only solution which remove all modding in wars for good.
the base is: supercell should remove pre-scouting in war.
Scout = simulations = modding and che***ting.
So clash community should know that we should give something to gain something else.
so my war proposal is:
- each player should setup 3 war base in prep day. All 3 war base cc will be filled by same troops in prep day to avoid conflict.
- in war day nobody can scout the opposite clan bases. they should create army and go attack one of the 3 bases of an opponent.
- when attacker hit attack button he/she has 3 minutes to scout the base and prepare for the attack.
- nobody can attack the base already attacked before. that means your clan only can attack a player 3 times.
- the best stars/destruction for each base will be count. for example if all 3 bases of one player attacked for 2 stars the one with more destruction will be count in war.
- The winning and losing rules is like as it is.


As you can see 3 minutes scout is the only difference from normal raids. IMO it is even more exciting. assume you are in pushing. everybody know that in high cups you should attack any base which offer good cups regardless of the base design. so it is more challenging.

Edit: of course you can see the opposite clan normal bases and find their troops, heroes and defenses level before attacks.

It will fix the issue indeed. However if i understand well in that case you prépare an army without knowing thé layout of the base you will attack ? Kind of removing interest of war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Damien79

It will fix the issue indeed. However if i understand well in that case you prépare an army without knowing thé layout of the base you will attack ? Kind of removing interest of war.

---

Yes. honestly I as a new th10 (but max offense except lab bk36 aq 32) can 3* 90% of th9 bases with golaloon regardless of base design.
Man we should propose a solution and IMO thats the only solution.
IMO we can sacrifice scouting benefits for something more important.
It is still fair. you cannot scout them and they cannot scout you

Honestly supercell should take doing something about the ♥♥♥♥♥ers very seriously. I've always laughed and trolled people who proclaim that they are quitting for rediculous reasons. However, I'm not sure I'm interested in playing if this becomes wide spread. I can't say that it has happened in a war I've been apart of yet but it worries me how much I've heard about it as of late on the forums. Who wants to play a game that isn't on the level. There are other games to play.

I already can see the so called "TH9 war community" jumping in their pants, if they can't plan the attack down to the tile, and bring the exact number of each troops, and without hours of planning.
:smirk:

As I understand it, from reading the forums, the base layout (traps and all) will be known the second a troop is dropped on a base.

Currently, people are complaining about single barb/archer drops by low level players, followed by a perfect 3 star by a high level player a few hours later.

It's not ..
> Scout = simulations = modding and che***ting.

It's
Low level Attack => simulation => Practice => high level 3 star


A solution would be to analyze attacks on the fly. If a pattern of low level scout attacks emerge, the entire war is automatically lost, instantly and the ♥♥♥♥♥ing players on the opposing team get banned, for good. Not 30 days, not a warning. The player is banned and the base goes into loot circulation.

Another solution could be: One attack per base. Easy and simple. Each player gets ONE attack.


/Affront

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Damien79

It will fix the issue indeed. However if i understand well in that case you prépare an army without knowing thé layout of the base you will attack ? Kind of removing interest of war.

---

I don't like the idea of not being able to plan your army. Perhaps if you could instantly train your army like they were able to do in the tournament. Still seems like it would take more away than you gain. They just need to be working towards a solution and they need to start being more open about the process. If we spend the gems on the game then they should at least work towards evening the playing field.

No extremely bad idea I suppose you don't have a high 10 account because just going at it with same armies over and over would ruin the the clanwar experience and if that's your motive you should instead trophy push which is basically the same with high stakes (trophies)

Clanwar is meant for proper planning and SCOUTING is the most important aspect of it. Killing diversity would ruin it more than someone just coming and tripling your base. If it affects how I attack I'm against it but bunnies against me do not. They can perfect me for all I care as long as I get a shot at their base.

A solution is allowing practise attacks for everyone. Anything else where you're handicapping attackers and especially in this case killing diversity will ruin the game.

♥♥♥♥s are from client side and these are very hard to stop.They are very smart and i am sure they will find another way to modify game and get a advantage and i dont like your idea.

Kill YouTube and you will remove the majority of the modders. With no audience and no glamour/glory/bragging rights most bunnies would feel demotivated enough to stop.

But obviously that isn't going to happen any time soon.