When we have monthly refresh, show # of clans member has been. clan hopper control

Printable View

November 14th, 2015
prosper12

When we have monthly refresh, show # of clans member has been. clan hopper control

We have talked many times about clan hoppers. An idea that can be implemented is when we have the monthly refresh u can also see how many clans person has been in previous month. This would deter clan hoppers from hopping very often. And we know we especially hate them when they leave in the middle of a war? It can be easily implemented . This way you would think twice by inviting someone that was hopping 10 or more times in the last month. This would not include getting kicked out.
November 15th, 2015
Radiating

This would mean displaying a negative statistic on profiles, which SC does not want to do. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.
November 15th, 2015
prosper12

Clan hopper deterrant - There should be some reason for them not to hop.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Radiating

This would mean displaying a negative statistic on profiles, which SC does not want to do. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.

This is by no means a negative statistic but rather a deterrent for players that hop to get quick troops and leave. And besides as a I said it would refresh every month. So that player would either have to slow down their hopping or just join a clan for the long run. This would be the RAID for clan hoppers.

Or if we can't have that their should be a maximum of hopping allowed. Come on people after hopping 10 clans after a month you should be either red flagged or at least supercell should say that is the 5th or 10th clan you have left in 5 days. If you leave this clan you will have to wait 24 hours before going on to a new clan.

There should be something in place. I would love to place anyone can join in my clan but that just floods the gate with hoppers.

Any suggestions on how we can deter clan hopping. Lets put our brains together people.
November 15th, 2015
ComingInKlutz

Quote:

Originally Posted by prosper12

This is by no means a negative statistic but rather a deterrent for players that hop to get quick troops and leave. And besides as a I said it would refresh every month. So that player would either have to slow down their hopping or just join a clan for the long run. This would be the RAID for clan hoppers.

Or if we can't have that their should be a maximum of hopping allowed. Come on people after hopping 10 clans after a month you should be either red flagged or at least supercell should say that is the 5th or 10th clan you have left in 5 days. If you leave this clan you will have to wait 24 hours before going on to a new clan.

There should be something in place. I would love to place anyone can join in my clan but that just floods the gate with hoppers.

Any suggestions on how we can deter clan hopping. Lets put our brains together people.

There is a significant problem with implementing this. The farmers who join the "Req N Leave" type clans would get red flagged because they go for troops and leave. This feature would ♥♥♥♥ them off because they'd have a bad reputation and would be unable to get CC troops for their raids. In addition Super Cell already ruled out features on this topic, just go read the stickies.
November 15th, 2015
prosper12

Clan hopper retreat.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ComingInKlutz

There is a significant problem with implementing this. The farmers who join the "Req N Leave" type clans would get red flagged because they go for troops and leave. This feature would ♥♥♥♥ them off because they'd have a bad reputation and would be unable to get CC troops for their raids. In addition Super Cell already ruled out features on this topic, just go read the stickies.

Why would you request troops from a clan and than leave? Isn't that another name for a hopper? Please elaborate. I have never heard of a request and leave clan. Why do they not just join a good farming clan that donates. To me that is just hopping. Or is that like a clan hopper retreat.