Tie Breaker ... is very frustrating

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Abushagrath

I'm not saying TH10 3STARS TH9 is an impressive I'm saying this is teamwork . Understanding the war ..
My friend I think my points are clear enough if you are still wondering come and see ,else I CAN SAY NOTHING MORE
And it was my pleasure to explain it to you .

---

Nor can I say much more to add, only that the opposition would have had to have used teamwork as well. I am pretty much happy with my understanding with this and any other war as it is.

Have you taken the offensive weight into your equation?
You keep focussing on the TH difference and Defensive difference, but what is your troops were maxed an theirs was not even close to that?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HungryHungryHippo

Have you taken the offensive weight into your equation?
You keep focussing on the TH difference and Defensive difference, but what is your troops were maxed an theirs was not even close to that?

---

I Already said it clearly .. in defences .. troops and royal

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ironagedave

Then by your very own ranking system your attack is cancelled out by the cowardly TH10 attack on the poor defenceless TH9. Sorry the argument is flawed you made a great attack don't get me wrong but it is cancelled out by the near dead cert of a 3 star from a th10 attacking a th9.

---

I think his point is that if you could 2 star the TH10 you should have been able to 3 star the TH9, leaving said TH10 for your TH10. This would have allowed your TH10 to beat your low 60%. Think of it this way.... If you had of three starred that TH9 and your TH10 got a 70-80% then you PROBABLY WOULD HAVE WON, if you did only lose by 1%. So your TEAMWORK didn't pay off. Just try again and be more aware of the TIE BREAKER that is now in place. My clan just lost on a tie breaker because myself and two other had bad attacks. You know what happened we learned from them. We regrouped, got back on the horse, and are ready to be more aware of total destruction percentages. You can say anything you want about it but the Tie Breaker is just fine. By your definition of teamwork you will never win a tie breaker unless the TH10 that YOU Personally attack is rushed and you get more than 70%.

Thanks for reading and Sorry OP but I think most people will agree with this comment

We had the same sort of problem, we got a big mistake match against a lvl 6 clan we are only lvl 3, so they had a big edge over us, but we won by 1% so I think the tie breaker is fine!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pympin

I think his point is that if you could 2 star the TH10 you should have been able to 3 star the TH9, leaving said TH10 for your TH10. This would have allowed your TH10 to beat your low 60%. Think of it this way.... If you had of three starred that TH9 and your TH10 got a 70-80% then you PROBABLY WOULD HAVE WON, if you did only lose by 1%. So your TEAMWORK didn't pay off. Just try again and be more aware of the TIE BREAKER that is now in place. My clan just lost on a tie breaker because myself and two other had bad attacks. You know what happened we learned from them. We regrouped, got back on the horse, and are ready to be more aware of total destruction percentages. You can say anything you want about it but the Tie Breaker is just fine. By your definition of teamwork you will never win a tie breaker unless the TH10 that YOU Personally attack is rushed and you get more than 70%.

Thanks for reading and Sorry OP but I think most people will agree with this comment

---

1. My firend my example is clear .. read the main thread carefully ..is not matter on this war only I'm talking in general

2. How did you mange to guess if I 2 star th10 that means I should 3 Stars Th9 ???? 2star strategy is far away deferent from 3star strategy ... in the end my loon is lvl 5 and my hog is lvl 4 ... you want me to 3 star th9 by barcher ? Hehehehe sorry but you faild even in your imagination ... finally I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT MY SPECIAL CASE ONLY IM ASKING TO ADJUST THE TIE BREAK SYSTEM TO BE MORE FAIR FOR ALL and I WAS AWARE ABOUT PERCENTAGE AND I KNOW WHAT HAPPENED

Have a nice clashing

Regards

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

We had the same sort of problem, we got a big mistake match against a lvl 6 clan we are only lvl 3, so they had a big edge over us, but we won by 1% so I think the tie breaker is fine!!!

---

Hehehe tell me your feeling if your opponent was a little bit better than what face and get th win by 1% even they are very much devolped than your clan and should win by 3 to 4 stars if they have the same skills as yours ;)

The difference in weight was above 30%....well that would be something, but you won't prove it. Firing off information as facts when it is just your thoughts will not get you far.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IUJimmy

The difference in weight was above 30%....well that would be something, but you won't prove it. Firing off information as facts when it is just your thoughts will not get you far.

---

Join the clan and check