Tie Breaker ... is very frustrating

We just lost one war .. it was unfair war ...

Our clan is
1 base mid 10..
4 bases mid 9 ... one is new 9 BTW
1 base max 8
1 base mid 8
3 bases mid 6

ENEMY clan is
1 base mid 10 ( defences , wall ,royal and troobs better than our 10 )
1 base new 10 ( not rushed )
3 bases ( nearly ) max 9 all better than our 9 bases in defences and wall and troobs
2 bases mid 9
1 base mid 8
1 base mid 7
1 base mid 6

We 3 stars 3 bases of them 9th and it ends 25 x 25 guess what they won becaus of 1% total destructions ONLY

but the defference in waight is more than 30%

Supercell .. I know mismatching could happen . BUT PLEASE CONSIDER THIS IN TIE BREAKER like
tie breaker shoud be total destruction mines or plus clan wight deference

An example :

Lets say theres a war between 1x1 not 10x10... or 15x15 or 20x20

The first is TH10 while the other is TH9 ...both they did 2 stars for each other ... in your opinon who is better ? In mine defently the TH9 is better in both defence layout and attacking strategy ... BUT according to the recent Tie breaker system TH10 is better because he get 2% total damage .... a stupid system


If you want to consider the damage percentage as a Tie breaker , defernces in clan wight should not be blinded.


P.S. ANY ONE FROM OTHER CLAN IS MORE THAN AN EQUAL IN US IN 20 LEVEL OR MORE

my clan is Mighty Invaders #GL8GLGJ if you want to come and watch

If if it was such an "unfair war" how did you manage a tie score with them in the first place?

I understand your frustration with unfair wars. However it is only fair that they are awarded the win when solely considering performance. As for avoiding future mismatches I suggest you use the 9 minute reset method.

Please provide us with your calculation of how you determined the weight difference between the two clans is 30%.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xav1

If if it was such an "unfair war" how did you manage a tie score with them in the first place?

---

Simply we get a tie because we played better than them in spite of the are much developed than us but we lost for the stupid tie breaker and as I said we success to 3stars 3 9th bases of them while they were able to 3star only 1 bases from us ... for more information come to my clan as vistor and see how we make this tie

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

I understand your frustration with unfair wars. However it is only fair that they are awarded the win when solely considering performance. As for avoiding future mismatches I suggest you use the 9 minute reset method.

---

Im suggesting to fix this issue for all not only for me or who reading this thread.. anyhow thanks for your advice

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JohnnyPC

Please provide us with your calculation of how you determined the weight difference between the two clans is 30%.

---

With a secret calculator . Hidden in the forbidden temble of the archer queen dude !

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Abushagrath

With a secret calculator . Hidden in the forbidden temble of the archer queen dude !

---

Did you use a war weight spreadsheet or was that an arbitrary number, I think that's what he's asking.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Did you use a war weight spreadsheet or was that an arbitrary number, I think that's what he's asking.

---

An arbitrary number ...anyhow the thread is not related to 20% , 10% or even 1% wight defernces Its related for a SUGGESTION . Not to explain match making mathmatics lol

I actually like the concept. We have only tied once and lost it, but it also adds extra importance to every attack. If you're in a close war and fairly low and know you can't get 3stars on a base, but can get a higher % on a low base, but no new stars, or go for loot on a higher base where you get one star and fewer percent, it adds an element of strategy.