Practice on already attacked base

Hello forum.
I just used an attack during my clan's current war against a base that I feel I should have done much better against. So to this effect, I was wondering if you guys think it would be cool if we could practice the attack AFTER we have already used it to learn from our mistakes.

Obviously only the first attack would count but I think it might be a good idea if we could practice the attack using THE SAME ARMY AND SPELL COMPOSITION once or maybe twice to see if we could have done better!

This could be to do with war and multiplayer!

Let me know what you guys think!

Happy clashing!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RhaegarTheDragonKnight

Hello forum.
I just used an attack during my clan's current war against a base that I feel I should have done much better against. So to this effect, I was wondering if you guys think it would be cool if we could practice the attack AFTER we have already used it to learn from our mistakes.

Obviously only the first attack would count but I think it might be a good idea if we could practice the attack using THE SAME ARMY AND SPELL COMPOSITION once or maybe twice to see if we could have done better!

This could be to do with war and multiplayer!

Let me know what you guys think!

Happy clashing!

---

There is a far easier way look at the replay over and over again was the spell timing off troops not durable enough, not well placed those are the three main factors for bad attacks - which you can pick up from the replays. Even repeating once would make attacking bases boring you only have one chance in life and one chance in war - it is far more exciting that way, get the adreneline going the heart pumping, which reminds me I'm due a checkup on my pacemaker...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ironagedave

There is a far easier way look at the replay over and over again was the spell timing off troops not durable enough, not well placed those are the three main factors for bad attacks - which you can pick up from the replays. Even repeating once would make attacking bases boring you only have one chance in life and one chance in war - it is far more exciting that way, get the adreneline going the heart pumping, which reminds me I'm due a checkup on my pacemaker...

---

Hahaha yeah fair enough. Perhaps I'm just bummed out because of a poor attack. Though maybe one more repetition wouldn't ruin the excitement too much.

It's an interesting idea. I think it would work fine with th5/6/7/8/9 but with th10, people have some of the same bases. The top players in Titans would lose a defenses badly because people constantly practice on the same bases. In the lower th levels, there is a wide variety of base designs so you can't practice all of them... It would be a huge loss to the top players who live coc that have th10 with the same couple of base designs... Good idea though!

I'd amend it so you can only practice after the ENTIRE WAR is done, not just when the first attack is done.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

I'd amend it so you can only practice after the ENTIRE WAR is done, not just when the first attack is done.

---

^this. I actually really like this idea, that after war is over one can run practice attacks against their opposition, but it should be limited to like 1 attack per player AND you should have to pay (and build) a new army of your choosing.

Hey guys! Thanks for all the comments. I agree perhaps TH10s might suffer though I think it'll only help weed out some of the more easy bases as attackers get more skilled and generally lead to a better game.
Yeah I know my idea isn't perfect. And perhaps allowing only one attack post war makes sense. That way you still learn from others mistakes by watching the replay.
And yeah, perhaps paying to train up a different army is a good idea as well!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RhaegarTheDragonKnight

Hello forum.
I just used an attack during my clan's current war against a base that I feel I should have done much better against. So to this effect, I was wondering if you guys think it would be cool if we could practice the attack AFTER we have already used it to learn from our mistakes.

Obviously only the first attack would count but I think it might be a good idea if we could practice the attack using THE SAME ARMY AND SPELL COMPOSITION once or maybe twice to see if we could have done better!

This could be to do with war and multiplayer!

Let me know what you guys think!

Happy clashing!

---

The idea is good, and it would be useful for war clans, however only one practice per attack. Also you can only practise after war.
There was a similar idea:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ttack-practice

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NF2335

The idea is good, and it would be useful for war clans, however only one practice per attack. Also you can only practise after war.
There was a similar idea:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ttack-practice

---

Cheers! Glad this has been brought up before. I wish supercell would take notice of one of these threads.