Clan Merger subforum removed!

Clan Merge its pointless because there is no people willing to merge to another clan everyone want people to merge in them even if his clan lvl1, all want to be leader its like a big deal plus this game is not about leading its about people get together and understand the concept of it ,,,, there is no progress in this section anyway only for very few clans and that's doesn't mean this section is necessary or important.

Even People don't respect your post, when you make one other people post their clans inside your post and they say ''Hey come merge in us if you interested'' while i made the post to make other clans to merge in mine, that's why i stop posting in clan merge while ago while i am in most need.

i am looking for the link for me to post about my clan looking for a merger> did they take that forum down?

This is one of the main reasons it was removed.
Clans were posting two recruitment threads, one in looking for clanmates, and one in clan mergers.
This is a violation of the forum rules, even if they contained slightly different text, they are still both recruitment threads.
Except for a few clans that wanted to merge into another clan, (who can now post in the "I need a clan" sub) it was just a way to advertise for mass recruits.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Inorlive

:thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::t humbsdown::thumbsdown:

As leader of a clan, I recently spend several hours writing a post for Clan Merger that was directed at other Clan Leaders and Officers about our clan strategy to merge with another clan. The content of that post was very different from the content of our normal recruitment post which was targeted at individual players that are looking for a new home.

Those forums had very different purposes and should exist independently.

Also, I no longer have access to my merger post that I spent a long time drafting.
Why are you trying to "fix" something that was not broken???

FYI:
Merger post:
We are a level 8 clan with 238 wins looking to merge with another clan.
You are a level 5+ clan of 5-25 people.

What we offer to the other clan is...
Our reason for wanting to merge is....
Of view on officers of the merged clan is that responsibility should be shared...
Our standards for he average player is... (less strict then for 1 person)
and so on targeted at Officers representing a clan.


For Individuals:
Looking for TH8-TH10
Minimum requirements are...
Application process is....
GroupMe & ClashCaller required.


This is the first time in 2 years that we are looking to add more then 1-2 players at a time.

Just restore the old forum....

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tinkerbell

This is one of the main reasons it was removed.
Clans were posting two recruitment threads, one in looking for clanmates, and one in clan mergers.
This is a violation of the forum rules, even if they contained slightly different text, they are still both recruitment threads.
Except for a few clans that wanted to merge into another clan, (who can now post in the "I need a clan" sub) it was just a way to advertise for mass recruits.

---

With all respect, I do not feel there was a violation and request you reconsider you decision. As I understand the forum rules you are not suppose to make multiple posts to different forums. If you read the two post I have in each forum, you would find they are SUBSTANTIALLY different, vs your characterization of "slightly".

Perhaps more importantly contrary to what some people have written the post I made in the "looking for merger" forum did generate a few leads of people who were leaving as a group and looking to join a new clan as a group. Issues like officers and clan management were addressed in the Merger forum post and obviously not part of the Looking for Members forum. Also, our requirements for a group/merger is different then our requirement for individuals.

In closing the posts were much more then slightly different (please go review them), and they were targeted at different audiences, and generated different inbound inquiry.

If as you say, people were duplicating posts, then clearly it should be one forum or the other, and duplicate posts should be deleted.

I hope this gets you to reconsider.
Clash On !!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Inorlive

With all respect, I do not feel there was a violation and request you reconsider you decision. As I understand the forum rules you are not suppose to make multiple posts to different forums. If you read the two post I have in each forum, you would find they are SUBSTANTIALLY different, vs your characterization of "slightly".

Perhaps more importantly contrary to what some people have written the post I made in the "looking for merger" forum did generate a few leads of people who were leaving as a group and looking to join a new clan as a group. Issues like officers and clan management were addressed in the Merger forum post and obviously not part of the Looking for Members forum. Also, our requirements for a group/merger is different then our requirement for individuals.

In closing the posts were much more then slightly different (please go review them), and they were targeted at different audiences, and generated different inbound inquiry.

If as you say, people were duplicating posts, then clearly it should be one forum or the other, and duplicate posts should be deleted.

I hope this gets you to reconsider.
Clash On !!!

---

If people are looking to move to a new clan in large numbers, they can find your recruitment thread in looking for clanmates. There is no need to have two recruitment threads ever.

I haven't used the "merger" thread before - just the "looking for clan mates" thread.

i am looking for a merger, not just to recruit, but because I need more leaders to help out. It's hard work right?

Where red should I go with that?