Printable View
Don't let new members in war.
In fact, a useful change would be this:
Force all new members to be opted out. (Nothing stops the leader from including them in war manually though).
This will help discourage inept leaders from including random flybys in war.
When the member is no longer "new", the member may then opt in.
To help this work smoothly, clans need to have a whitelist, a list of players who may come and go at will, returning to their normal rank, not returning to be labelled "new".
Yes, you're not the only one to agree. There are also a bunch of Clashers here who do not like having members leave during Wars. And just because I said "you're not the only one to agree" doesn't mean I'm one of them, I said it because I know a lot of Leaders and Co-Leaders who hated those.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scunner
Finally, it's a no. It's not gonna happen in the game. No, why? Reasons why:
- Feeder Clans
- The Leader temporarily leaves the main Clan to visit a feeder Clan and check on something. But to do that, the Leader has to wait 24-48 hours to get into the feeder and back to the main Clan.
- RAL (Request and Leave) Clans
- As the clan's name suggests: Request AND Leave. One joins, requests for troops, then leaves to get back to his/her main Clan. But to get into one after leaving, they have to wait 24-48 hours and another 24-48 hours to get back into the main Clan, which the other clanmates of the main clan thinks s/he left forever.
- Merged (or Allied) Clans
- A trusted member leaves the clan and visits the merged/allied clan. In order to do this, the player waits for 24-48 hours to get in and back, in which the player's clanmates in the other clan may think s/he has deserted the clan.
Now you know the reasons why I disagree?
Quote:
Originally Posted by DARWINIANS
See now that's more reasonable right there. However I don't mean if one leaves anytime they get clan banned I meant the server recognizes one player who's in a clan war and sees they left in the middle of it not before the war or preparation .
Any automatic punishment is a bad idea. Period. There are valid reasons for being a war deserter.
I do, however, support the idea of giving clans better access to player history information. Then each clan can decide how relevant that information is on their own.
Stunner, I believe you should divert attention away from people leaving your clan and bring the attention to WHY everyone is leaving.
Based on what that guy said earlier - any clan that uses barch and giant and healers for war are a trash clan. I didn't even think people used that for war attacks anymore...
The biggest factor is how much your clan wins. If people see how much your clan loses and see how your clan attacks, then people will be tempted to leave. I would defintely leave if someone used barch on an attack,that is down right ridiculous and unacceptable. If you have the authority to, i would kick whoever uses non war strategies instantly. And make that apparent in clan mail.
NOTE: good players check war logs, and if you have more red (lost wars) than green (won wars) they are likely not to stay. Good players also leave when hey detect your clan is inactive, which is what I'm assuming is what happening in your clan.
Scunner, if you're not the leader of that clan, I would suggest you leave that clan to join a clan that actually knows what they are doing and how to properly run and use war attacks.
Lots of people use request & leave clans to get war troops. Typically it happens when they're in a clan with only a couple of folks who can donate max troops. They are in a war, they leave and get a max troop they need, then they return to their home clan to do their war attacks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scunner
Heck the opposite happens in lots of feeder/family clans. My clan wars constantly, so I'm always in prep or war. There are often requests on our message boards asking someone to pop over and donate a troop (often at weird hours when most aren't on).
I've said it before but I'll say it again...most ideas which essentially force Supercell into running a clan for you are not good ideas. They only come about because of poor clan leadership, and effectively punish those running clans well either by limiting their options or by keeping poorly led clans running.