More reward for clan wars

Printable View

October 27th, 2015
TreePerson

More reward for clan wars

Sorry I'm sure this has been suggested tons of times but being a noob I couldn't find a post where it has been discussed and the idea hasn't been ruled out so I just had to make a post to vent.

I think there really needs to be more reward for winning or even participating in a clan war. When you participate in a clan war you expend a lot of resources on expensive troops and not mention all the donations. If you lose, obviously the reward doesn't make up for the costs. But if you win, you still get a lost in dark elixir and the reward in gold and elixir compared to how much you would get farming is only above average which is not enough to justify the time it took to plan your war attacks (speaking from a th9). So I'm not surprised when people are too lazy to attack in a war.

The only other motivation I have for participating in a clan war is the thrill of it, but I think it's important for a good reward to justify your effort. It would be more exciting if the loot bonus was higher and also make it more efficient than farming.

I know that higher clan levels get a slight increase in war bonuses but that is a long way away and still only a small increase.

Anyway I haven't done any exact calculations here, I might be just talking out my butt haha but gj so far on everything supercell, I'm looking forward to the new update.
October 27th, 2015
Radiating

This would be nice but it would decrease the incentive to perform well somewhat and this would be an automatic win for the FWA.
October 27th, 2015
herranton

Quote:

Originally Posted by Radiating

This would be nice but it would decrease the incentive to perform well somewhat and this would be an automatic win for the FWA.

Lol@fwa... Farm war association?

I think the loot in war is fine. It isn't for making a profit, it is for bragging rights. I don't come close to breaking even once filling cc and donating for war attacks. But I like to win and I like to get the clan together, come up with a plan and win the war. That is enough motivation. I would probably still war if there was no loot to be gained.
October 27th, 2015
blueseraph79

Quote:

Originally Posted by herranton

Lol@fwa... Farm war association?

I think the loot in war is fine. It isn't for making a profit, it is for bragging rights. I don't come close to breaking even once filling cc and donating for war attacks. But I like to win and I like to get the clan together, come up with a plan and win the war. That is enough motivation. I would probably still war if there was no loot to be gained.

haha. FWA umm.. FRAUD WASTE AND ABUSE?

Anyway, I wouldn't war if there was no loot to gain. It's a waste of effort. The bragging rights? you can't brag to the clan you are about to defeat because you both cant see each other anyway. Doing so in the clan message board might get you reported to Supercell for Abuse.

About your suggestion OP, its nice but I think SC already made the loot bonus by giving clan rewards bonuses to war loots.

Also, make sure all your team donates so it wouldn't hurt much if you lose. Or just farm the resource what you have lost.

I think its to promote team effort. :o
October 27th, 2015
TreePerson

Quote:

Originally Posted by herranton

Lol@fwa... Farm war association?

I think the loot in war is fine. It isn't for making a profit, it is for bragging rights. I don't come close to breaking even once filling cc and donating for war attacks. But I like to win and I like to get the clan together, come up with a plan and win the war. That is enough motivation. I would probably still war if there was no loot to be gained.

Yes bragging rights is a decent incentive, although imo not as important as loot, but just like the previous reply, what is there to brag about? You can't message the other clan, your win loss ratio doesn't show and apart from the top, top clans theres no real leader board to show your clan is doing well in wars.

It just depends of whether you want this game to be more about grinding or skill?
October 27th, 2015
kdrakakis

I think that a significant improvement to war loot bonus would be to award it as a genuine bonus in excess of any war cost incurred. So, the cost of filling up cc's should be refunded to donating players 100%, as should be the cost of the army plus the spells. The war bonus would then be awarded on top of that, and I think in this case the current values of the bonus are appropriate.

As things stand today, some army compositions are just way too expensive, especially if the clan does not win the war (like, for example, full dragon in terms of elixir, or gowiwi and goho in terms of dark elixir).
October 27th, 2015
TreePerson

Quote:

Originally Posted by kdrakakis

I think that a significant improvement to war loot bonus would be to award it as a genuine bonus in excess of any war cost incurred. So, the cost of filling up cc's should be refunded to donating players 100%, as should be the cost of the army plus the spells. The war bonus would then be awarded on top of that, and I think in this case the current values of the bonus are appropriate.

As things stand today, some army compositions are just way too expensive, especially if the clan does not win the war (like, for example, full dragon in terms of elixir, or gowiwi and goho in terms of dark elixir).

Yes I agree, a refund of all troops and spells used in the war plus some bonus loot.

Or another idea is clan war win streak bonus. Just anything to give more incentive for clan wars so people are more willing to do their best.
October 29th, 2015
TreePerson

Can I bump this thread? Is there no one else who is for or against this idea?
October 29th, 2015
Xav1

Quote:

Originally Posted by TreePerson

Yes I agree, a refund of all troops and spells used in the war plus some bonus loot.

Or another idea is clan war win streak bonus. Just anything to give more incentive for clan wars so people are more willing to do their best.

If you are in a clan that aren't willing to do "to do their best" then you are either in the wrong clan or the clan leadership is lacking. Winning the war is enough incentive to do your best. Plus there are the clan perks, which reward the clan with additional war loot, refund on donations, troop level up, etc. etc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TreePerson

Can I bump this thread? Is there no one else who is for or against this idea?

No, you are not allowed to bump your own thread.