Heroes maxed level idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Melitto

1. I am a maxed out th9 ( defenses and WALLS) with heroes level 20 and 21. To actually spend time to built my walls means I actually play the game a lot.
2. I concider myself a very good player with lots of 3 star attacks on th9. Gowipe with 6 hogs, golavaloon, goho. Those are my favorite types of attacks. I never attack with a stereotype attack. I always make slight changes to a general type of attack based on the opponents base weakness. Thus I have a high rate of 3 star attacks.
3. I have build a base that had given me 65 defenses in less than a week when I was at 3300 trophies as a th9.

Thus us I believe I know a few things about what I am talking about.
A. I do not disagree that the amount of dark elixir I proposed might be too high. Let's concider a lower amount.
B. I assume the real disadvantage of this idea would be how to implement it if a th11 upgrade ever comes out and as someone mentioned above you would perhaps get a 10 level upgrade capability.

---

I wasn't questioning your ability, I was questioning whether you are a max TH10. I think you're not giving sufficient weight to the idea that completely maxing out is the only time you can actually get equal to a gemmed base. It's psychological, the idea that you can basically never get to the point that someone who gems can if this were implemented. You've basically been banned from ever being maxed out unless you spend gems.

IMO a much better suggestion would simply be adding 10 more hero levels to each hero. Gemmers can gem them immediately. Farmers can work towards them in a reasonable amount of time. There's a reasonable return on the investment of all that DE and time. It would take long enough for farmers there wouldn't be an immediate "ok I'm done, but now what" (it would take probably 6 months minimum for most, most likely a year because they'll want to war sometimes too). It wouldn't allow gemmers to get SO far ahead of a point that farmers could reasonably achieve.

I think from a balancing perspective this doesn't hurt much. It's slightly easier to 3 star TH10s with this. But TH10 only has 10 hero levels apiece as it is, making it 20 doesn't seem such a big deal. The real issue to a max TH10 is the time a hero will be upgrading given that all they have left to do is war...and how long it's going to take them to get caught up to whatever the new "max" is to catch their peers who are gemming. The DE cost is annoying, but not a problem with fundamental game play. The other 2 issues are gameplay issues.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Melitto

Dude you fail to see the point. Maxed th10 players do not have anything to do right now...

---

go outside?

edited to add: And I don't mean to a place where you can get LTE coverage for clashing...

I would really like to make a vote box for people to vote but I don't really know how to make it. Anyone care to help please?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nerfedname

go outside?

edited to add: And I don't mean to a place where you can get LTE coverage for clashing...

---

♥♥♥♥.


OP: you seem very attached to your idea, but pretty much everyone commenting is telling you why it's a bad one. As someone with level 20 heroes, you should also know that heroes already take up a lot of resources for relatively little return...individual upgrades already offer a negligible difference, and in order to get an ability upgrade you're looking at like 500k in DE and over a month of down time where you don't have access to your hero, which takes away from the fun of the game since it impacts your ability to trophy push and war. IMO Supercell already does a pretty good job of balancing the added strength you get for hero upgrades relative to cost, and whether it's added for TH10 or TH11, I think we'll eventually be seeing more levels of hero, but they should stick to the same basic progression SC has already developed for hero upgrades.

I'm not sure why you're worried about "players with nothing to do" since you're nowhere near that yourself, but the end game is supposed to be about trophy pushing, not upgrading your base and troops indefinitely, so they DO in fact have something to do still. In fact, as someone with heroes similar to yours, I'm actually relieved when I take a break from upgrading them, and would rather have other things to spend DE on because while it's nice to get stronger heroes, I hate having them down for long periods because my multiplayer attacks are less satisfying, and I'm either not warring or not able to contribute to the war effort at the level I normally can.

Please find the time to read and vote in my new thread about the heroes max level idea. I appreciate your effort. Thanks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Melitto

I would really like to make a vote box for people to vote but I don't really know how to make it. Anyone care to help please?

---

You can't edit in a poll, you'll have to use something like strawpoll.